Skip to main content
BusinessesMap
Pesto, Sutton Coldfield — Italian Restaurants in Sutton Coldfield

Pesto, Sutton Coldfield

Italian RestaurantsSutton Coldfield, ENG

4.5 out of 5 stars4.5(1,952 reviews)

Quick info

+44 121 329 3203
20 Hollyfield Rd S, The Royal Town of Sutton Coldfield, Birmingham, Sutton Coldfield B76 1NX, United Kingdom

About Pesto, Sutton Coldfield

On Hollyfield Rd S in Sutton Coldfield, Pesto occupies a former pub, keeping parquet flooring and an open fire while serving Italian food across several distinct areas for dining or a drink at the bar. The menu offers fixed price options alongside individual choices from the main list, with dishes such as peposo, Alfredo con spinaci, and linguine al cartoccio, and portions built for ordering several plates to share. Wine comes by the bottle or the glass. Seating runs on a walk-in basis rather than reservation. The room can fill up on busy evenings, and the lighting stays low enough that reading the menu takes some effort.

Good to know

“This former pub now serves Italian food amid elegant decor with parquet-flooring and an open fire.”

  • Reservations
    Walk-in only
  • Accessibility
    Wheelchair: entrance, parking lot, restroom, seating

Reviews

4.5/5
1,952 reviews

What reviewers say

Reviewers most often mention small portion sizes, good value for money, wide menu variety and fixed price menu options.

5★
1,354
4★
394
3★
112
2★
39
1★
53

Customer Review Summary

Reviewers most often point to variety, describing meals built from small plates and multiple dishes, such as ribs, Alfredo con spinaci, peposo and linguine al cartoccio ordered together to sample the menu, alongside praise for attentive, friendly service and a warm, relaxed atmosphere in the fixed-price and à la carte format. Value comes up repeatedly too, with several calling prices reasonable or good for the quality. Close behind, though, is a recurring complaint about portion sizes being small, and one diner found several dishes, including the ribs and peposo, tasted like they'd been sitting out, with the linguine sent back over its smell; another noted heavy saltiness they attributed to MSG. One reviewer also describes a staff member repeatedly commenting on their family's accent, leaving them uncomfortable despite otherwise enjoying the food and setting. A separate visitor mentioned the low lighting made the menu hard to read, on an evening that still came to a modest bill for four.

Featured reviews

  • Google user
    “Pleasant clean interior with several different areas for dining or bar. Very comprehensive Italian menu choices from three fixed price menus to individual choices from a main menu. Good value, enjoyable food and friendly service. Decent wine choice by bottle or glass. Would certainly visit again.”
  • Google user
    “I wish I could give Pesto 7-stars. We had a amazing experience there. From the warm welcome to getting our meals, we were well looked after. Being my first time in the area, I was unsure of what to expect, but it exceeded mu expectation. Great menu, fairly priced with options for everyone. Top notch service from Kiera. Definitely worth a visit.”
  • Google user
    “We visited Pesto yesterday and were absolutely delighted with the whole experience. From the moment we arrived, everyone was incredibly friendly and welcoming. The service was attentive, efficient and genuinely warm, making us feel very comfortable throughout our visit. The restaurant has a lovely, cosy atmosphere, and every dish we ordered was fresh and absolutely delicious. What impressed us even more was the outstanding value for money. The quality of the food, the excellent service and the welcoming atmosphere were exceptional, especially considering the very reasonable prices. We left genuinely impressed and will definitely be coming back. Pesto has become one of our favourite restaurants, and we look forward to visiting again very soon. Highly recommended!”
  • Google user
    “They definitely nailed the British brief here: fantastic ambiance, but the food seems designed for people who think black pepper is too spicy. First of all, the portions are tiny. When we complained about having to mix mismatched dishes, the waitress seriously suggested ordering the exact same dish three times. We ordered the ribs, Alfredo con spinaci, peposo, and linguine al cartoccio. As a meat lover, the ribs and peposo tasted like they had been sitting around for days. The Alfredo was completely tasteless, and the linguine smelled so bad we sent it right back. If you only care about a nice room and nice wallpaper, you’ll love it. If you actually want edible food, do not waste your time."”
  • Google user
    “We genuinely enjoyed the food and the atmosphere at Pesto Sutton Coldfield, which is why I'm disappointed to be writing this review. During our visit, my husband, our three-year-old daughter and I were speaking Persian together. A member of staff, who was also Iranian, approached us and asked if we were Iranian. After we said yes, he told us twice that he could tell from our accent. I understand that he may not have intended to be unkind, but the comment left me feeling self-conscious. What saddened me most was my three-year-old daughter asking me afterwards, "Mummy, do we speak strangely?" She speaks English with a British accent because she attends nursery here, while my husband and I speak English as a second language. I don't believe there is anything wrong with having an accent. Everyone has one, including the member of staff. However, repeatedly pointing ours out made us feel uncomfortable and had an unexpected impact on our daughter. I hope this feedback is taken constructively. Pesto is a lovely restaurant, and I simply hope all customers, regardless of where they come from or how they speak, are made to feel equally welcome and respected.”

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
Show more amenities
Accessibility· 3
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating

Location

Italian Restaurants near Pesto, Sutton Coldfield

Pesto, Sutton Coldfield
4.51,952

The 3 nearest italian restaurants by distance. Ratings, hours and review terms come from public business profiles.

Browse more

Explore more of Sutton Coldfield, or find Restaurants in other cities.

DirectionsCallTop