
Sugar Factory
American restaurantNew York, NY
“Due to state wide mandates, we are open until 12AM but our last seating is at 11PM. Thank you, The Sugar Factory Family”
Advertisements
Quick info
About Sugar Factory
Sugar Factory is an American restaurant in New York, NY, at 1991 Broadway, where birthday celebrations arrive at the table with candles and singing. Guests give the birthday when they reserve, and it is noted on the reservation. The menu lists 20 dishes, including Fried Macaroni & Cheese Pops, Buttermilk Onion Rings and Quesadillas. Sugar Factory ice cream and desserts are part of the offering, and milkshakes are on the menu too.
Advertisements
Menu & Prices
20 dishes · mains $8–28- Basket Of Fries$8.00
- Guacamole$12.00
- Buttermilk Onion Rings$12.00
- Chicken Fingers$13.00
- Fried Macaroni & Cheese Pops$16.00
- Quesadillas$15.00
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention ice cream desserts, birthday celebration, huge portions and milkshakes.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention ice cream desserts, birthday celebration, huge portions and milkshakes.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers who praise Sugar Factory point first to the ice cream and desserts, especially for birthday celebrations, where staff put on an event described as memorable and fun, with decor that makes a beautiful backdrop for photos. Others cite huge portions that match the prices and service that treated a young guest kindly. The complaints are more numerous, though, and center on slow service. Diners describe waiters who never checked back, an order that never arrived, food landing so far apart that one person finished before the other was served, and tepid coffee with no refill. One party says a birthday noted on the reservation and mentioned repeatedly went unacknowledged while other tables got candles and singing. A couple object to an automatic 20% service charge, and one says walk-ins without a reservation were treated as if they didn't matter. Several walked out, one table leaving without four milkshakes and another buying the kids cookies around the corner instead.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers who praise Sugar Factory point first to the ice cream and desserts, especially for birthday celebrations, where staff put on an event described as memorable and fun, with decor that makes a beautiful backdrop for photos. Others cite huge portions that match the prices and service that treated a young guest kindly. The complaints are more numerous, though, and center on slow service. Diners describe waiters who never checked back, an order that never arrived, food landing so far apart that one person finished before the other was served, and tepid coffee with no refill. One party says a birthday noted on the reservation and mentioned repeatedly went unacknowledged while other tables got candles and singing. A couple object to an automatic 20% service charge, and one says walk-ins without a reservation were treated as if they didn't matter. Several walked out, one table leaving without four milkshakes and another buying the kids cookies around the corner instead.
Featured reviews
- Kenya Woods
“Absolutely great place such huge portions. Very good service. Treated my lil princess and my friend very kindly. Prices really matched the size of portions given.”
- Amanda Crase
“Let’s start with the waitress. Horrible. No other word to describe her. Chenet was slow, rude and just didn’t care. Both drinks were horrible. We took one sip out of both of them and left the rest on the table..couldn’t ask for replacements because she didn’t come back until she asked for my credit card to pay the bill. Didn’t ask if we needed anything, didn’t ask if the food was good (which is wasn’t because it didn’t have any of the extras we needed because like I said she didn’t come back). They act as if your nothing when you “don’t have a reservation”. Wasn’t busy so no reason for slow service.. but then again I guess Chenet had super important business to attend on her cell phone like we weren’t sitting right there and couldn’t see her. Then someone asked for the manager to see if she could hang a poster up and the lady manager (dark hair glasses) told her we can’t hang things up; okay that’s fine but then before the women even walked away she looked at one of her workers and screamed “was that so hard?” Meaning why couldn’t you tell her this. Like really? So rude. Nasty attitude for a “manager” then the manager asked a trainee if she was trained enough and could she be sent on her own to do.. like seriously? Aren’t you a manager and your running your mouth in front of customers. And on top of it not one not two but THREE tables got tired of waiting and got up and left. Like we should have done. Oh yeah and tell your guests they are gonna be charged an extra $20 for a service tip even if they only get in reality $40 worked of things and have to spend $100. Horrible staff horrible food 0/5 if possible”
- Amy Shaflik
“We had a similar experience to others. Waited too long to have our simple order taken, the order never came after a ridiculous amount of time so we left. We got the kids cookies around the corner instead.”
- Oliver Jewell
“Did not receive 4 milkshakes after 40 minutes didn't even tell us and so we walked out”
- jason grant
“Utterly awful. Food was poor and arrived 20 mins apart which is ridiculous when 2 people are eating. I had finished before my son’s food arrived. Coffee was tepid at best and no refill offered. Cold inside due to the broken window. To make matters worse they automatically add a 20% service charge which I assume lets them provide such atrocious service. Avoid is my recommendation. Had to give 1 star when zero stars is more appropriate”
Location
Restaurants near Sugar Factory
- La Grande Boucherie4.610,4090.9 mi$50–100Good for kidsReservations
steak frites, escargot, crème brûlée
- Le Bernardin4.64,6011 mi$80–90Reservations
poached lobster, bread service, chocolate tart
- 1 miVegan optionsWheelchair accessibleGood for kids
picanha, salad bar, cheese bread
| Place | Rating | Distance | Price | Mentioned in reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sugar Factory | 3.72,405 | — | — | ice cream desserts, birthday celebration, huge portions |
| La Grande BoucherieGood for kids · Reservations | 4.610,409 | 0.9 mi | $50–100 | steak frites, escargot, crème brûlée |
| Le BernardinReservations | 4.64,601 | 1 mi | $80–90 | poached lobster, bread service, chocolate tart |
| Churrascaria Plataforma SteakhouseVegan options · Wheelchair accessible · Good for kids | 4.54,197 | 1 mi | — | picanha, salad bar, cheese bread |
The 3 nearest restaurants by distance. Ratings, hours and review terms come from public business profiles.
Similar Restaurants nearby
1 mithe Press Lounge
1.3 miJacob's Pickles
1.4 miBuena Vista Restaurant & Bar
1.6 miBeyond Sushi Vegan Restaurant
1.9 miBaekjeong NYC
2.6 miGramercy Tavern
2.6 miLOS TACOS No.1
2.9 miMORENO
More to explore in New York

53 places
Restaurants in New York
Photo: Katz's Delicatessen · 4.5 · 53,559 Google reviews
See all 53 restaurants in New York