Eataly

Featured reviews

• L

  Livan Herrera

  ·1 month ago

  “This spot is a gem! The pizza is the absolute standout—it’s so authentic and the ingredients are so fresh that it feels like a slice of Italy. ​The atmosphere is fantastic, and the staff does a great job maintaining a clean and welcoming environment. Best of all, the service is incredibly quick and professional without ever feeling rushed. It’s the perfect place for a high-quality meal that doesn't keep you waiting. I’ll definitely be back!”

• N

  Nathan Alcock

  ·2 months ago

  “Food was incredible, 5 star all round and great views of the 911 memorial. definitely a good stop if your in the area. I was also surprised that we didn’t need to book only down side was a fish smell that came from the store area but that isnt really something they could fix.”

• B

  Brett Montclair

  ·3 months ago

  “A school lunch tasted better. Another so so restaurant but not in a so so place. It’s not well planned or organized. My Asian guests were puzzled not on the concept but on the quality of food. Each dish was limo, sad, almost tasteless. I thought maybe dessert would save the meal. NOT. SADLY, one guess needed the loo. It’s not well delineated or marked. They threw up in a bag that luckily we had. A sad night with a very mediocre meal. One guess asked how do they keep all this food fresh. I said this is NYC not a third world city.”

• K

  Kate Rimolo

  ·4 months ago

  “Love this location. It’s super convenient in the Financial District and offers a great food and grocery option. They usually have any items on sale, but this time they didn’t. They have two restaurants. I prefer La pizza & la pasta. The gelato is also delicious.”

• B

  Bertha Cruz

  ·4 months ago

  “I absolutely love this place! The ambience is so upbeat! So may people walking around shopping or simply enjoying a glass of wine as they are shopping. The main issue I had it was that I couldn’t make up my mind on what to eat. I have been here so many times and yet, I always go through this. I ended up buying a pasta dish and sat by myself in a quieter area. I had the company of a tiny bird who seemed so out of place here, but nevertheless I truly enjoyed his company.”

• P

  Piangporn Thongprong

  ·4 months ago

  “I recently visited Eataly’s pasta restaurant and the food was absolutely amazing. The pasta was fresh, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor. You can really taste the quality of the ingredients. Definitely some of the best pasta I’ve had. However, the service at the cashier was disappointing. The lady taking my order (she had noticeable fake eyelashes and was seated the whole time) came across as rude and uninterested. She seemed disengaged and not very welcoming, which didn’t match the high standard of the food or the restaurant itself.”

• M

  Mitre Krajoski

  ·5 months ago

  “I’ve been here several times, mainly because I stay at a hotel just across the street. Every visit, getting a table is difficult. I’ve tried breakfast, brunch, and lunch. The food quality is excellent—really very good—but the prices are extremely high and, in my opinion, overpriced for what you get. Unfortunately, the overall experience doesn’t match the quality of the food. The place is very busy and noisy, making it hard to relax and enjoy the meal. The staff are not very polite or communicative, and I never experienced a welcoming attitude or even a smile. One particularly annoying experience was when I ordered a pizza for takeaway. The pizza was already prepared and sitting in front of me, but because the staff member I ordered from wasn’t there, I was forced to wait another 10 minutes just for confirmation—even though there was only one pizza and one order. Because of the high prices, noisy atmosphere, and poor service, despite the excellent food quality, I would rate this place as average”

• R

  R Garcia

  ·5 months ago

  “We ordered fritto misto and bruschetta for apps. Pastas and pizzas for entree. Everything was soooo good! Portioning is just right. Pizza crust was light. Kids loved the pastas we had no leftovers.”

• A

  Amin Asgharzadeh

  ·5 months ago

  “It’s always refreshing to visit Eataly, especially when you finally find what you’ve been searching for! We have been looking forward to trying their famous pistachio croissant for a long time. After visiting two other Eataly locations …”

• N

  Nicky

  ·6 months ago

  “Eataly New York is a great place to experience authentic Italian food in the heart of the city. During our visit, we tried several traditional dishes and everything was delicious. …”