Skip to main content
BusinessesMap

Italian restaurants in New York, NY

5 italian restaurants · 12,223+ reviews

The 5 italian restaurants currently listed in New York together carry more than 12,000 customer reviews, spanning from about 400 to over 6,200. Their ratings sit close together, from 4.4 to 4.6, for a combined average of 4.5. All 5 open at least one weekend day, and 5 of them open seven days a week. Casa D'angelo New York holds the highest rating. Each entry below shows its address, current opening hours, photos and a short summary, so rating, review volume and location are easy to compare at a glance.

5 italian restaurants

Italian restaurants in New York, ranked by rating and reviews

Casa D'angelo New YorkSee menu

Casa D'angelo New York

Italian Restaurant

4.6(6,289)$15–30New York

Known for: tableside cheese wheel pasta, truffle pasta, pesto gnocchi, carbonara

Da Andrea Greenwich VillageSee menu

Da Andrea Greenwich Village

Italian Restaurant

4.6(2,645)$30–90New York

Known for: cappellacci al tartufo, butternut squash, burrata, carbonara

La Lanterna di VittorioSee menu

La Lanterna di Vittorio

Italian Restaurant

4.5(2,434)$20–60New York

Known for: lasagna flights, tiramisu, bruschetta, garden patio seating

Forsythia NYCSee menu

Forsythia NYC

Italian Restaurant

4.4(440)$80–90New York

Known for: agnolotti, 22% service fee, unfriendly host, handmade pasta

BacaroSee menu

Bacaro

Italian Restaurant

4.4(415)$50–60New York

Known for: rustic cellar downstairs dining, spaghetti with clams, duck cavatelli, fritto misto and eggplant parm

How this list works: businesses are shown from public profiles and can be sorted by rating or review count. No business can pay for placement or to push down a competitor.