
Papa Johns Pizza
Advertisements
Quick info
About Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza is a pizza restaurant at 289 Ecclesall Rd in Sheffield. Its pizzas include the Chicken Fajita, and the Original Hand-Tossed Dough is one of the crust options. Vegan and gluten-free pizzas sit alongside them, with the plant based options labelled. The team at the front takes orders, makes the pizzas and hands them over, and the Papa Johns app is another way to place an order. Customers who sign up to Papa Rewards earn points on each order.
Good to know
- ParkingFree street parking
- AccessibilityWheelchair: entrance
- DietaryVegan options · Vegetarian options
Advertisements
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention hand-tossed crust, vegan gluten-free pizza, chicken fajita pizza and app payment failures.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention hand-tossed crust, vegan gluten-free pizza, chicken fajita pizza and app payment failures.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers most often single out the pizza itself, especially the crust. The Original Hand-Tossed Dough is described as pillowy, slightly sweet and fresh-baked, and the Chicken Fajita pizza as delicious and full of flavour. Toppings are repeatedly called fresh and generous, and one reviewer praises the vegan and gluten free options, including a pizza that is both. Staff draw frequent praise as friendly, quick and professional, with several saying their orders were prepared fast and correctly. The complaints are fewer but specific. Two reviewers report wrong items, and one says delivery through Stuart arrived cold. One says a card was charged for an order the website never registered, and that the app avoided this, though the money took a few days to return. Another describes a wrong pizza where staff refused a refund, and a manager who called back late only to point the customer to a help line.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers most often single out the pizza itself, especially the crust. The Original Hand-Tossed Dough is described as pillowy, slightly sweet and fresh-baked, and the Chicken Fajita pizza as delicious and full of flavour. Toppings are repeatedly called fresh and generous, and one reviewer praises the vegan and gluten free options, including a pizza that is both. Staff draw frequent praise as friendly, quick and professional, with several saying their orders were prepared fast and correctly. The complaints are fewer but specific. Two reviewers report wrong items, and one says delivery through Stuart arrived cold. One says a card was charged for an order the website never registered, and that the app avoided this, though the money took a few days to return. Another describes a wrong pizza where staff refused a refund, and a manager who called back late only to point the customer to a help line.
Featured reviews
- E.
“I’ve been forgetting to update my previous review, please accept my apologies. Their pizzas are amazing, they have vegan options, gluten free options and even Vegan and Gluten free at the same time which is rare on takeaways to find and be as delicious as fulfilling as this is. It is labelled as plant based right? Be aware that of course there can be some cross contamination as they also cook other things but then again is usually expected in general right? Years as a client of them, in this specific branch, have gave me the chance to notice: Papa Johns Pizza App is the best option to order, wether for collection or delivery, the App seems to bypass their Papa Johns Pizza back and forth payment failure where clients can get charge for an order that their system doesn’t compute (then you can contact this local branch via phone call or/and with you own bank directly, it would take a few days for the money to be returned to your bank account. I don’t recommend to automatically assume it would be returned without letting them know just in case). I haven’t tried to contact Papa Johns Pizza directly instead of this local branch the several times that payment issue happened to me because I’ve assume it would be potentially costly if is a phone call, or/and taken way too much time navigating the bureaucracy of waiting them to pass the message to themselves to solving it (which is usually the standard issue with services in general isn’t it?). I am not good remembering names, my apologies. One of the staff members who is usually on the front receiving people and giving orders as well as making pizzas too, he is one of their most understanding, kind people one can find in the food industry. And he also usually picks up the phone when you call to them. Thank you very much I hope you enjoy your job cause you really are good at it even with annoying clients frustration over website payment failures. 🙈😃 They also have friendly delivery drivers (if for some reason it is not delivered by third parties such as Uber which sorry not sorry usually seem to be too stressed out / busy / in a hurry to be more friendly most of the time). I take out one star out five stars because of the website payment issue and also one day I’ve seen in person there where some flies around which is a bit unpleasant to see on a food chain place but it would probably be just the hot weather? It was in summer 2026.”
- Dominic Hanscomb
“I came here and KP served me and he was phenomenal. Made me feel comfortable and made my order very fast and ready. Very good Papa Johns”
- Laila Sinan
“The pizza was best we ate ever in Sheffield, and the staff really kind and specially Abhay he understood what we needed particularly and help us.”
- Avinash Kavala
“Absolutely loved my experience at Papa John’s! 🍕 The pizza was incredibly fresh, loaded with toppings, and full of flavor in every bite. The crust was perfectly baked—crispy on the outside and soft inside—and the cheese was just the right amount. You can really tell they use quality ingredients. A big shoutout to Linga and Abhay for their excellent service—they were friendly, quick, and made the experience even better. Definitely one of the tastiest pizzas I’ve had in a while. Highly recommend if you’re craving something delicious!”
- Manasi Patil
“⭐ Great pizzas with fresh toppings and generous portions. The Chicken Fajita pizza was delicious, full of flavour, and cooked perfectly. Special thanks to Nagendra for the excellent and friendly service. great overall experience!”
Hours
- Monday
- Tuesday
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
Highlights
“Papa Johns. Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. 100% fresh dough in all of our pizzas. Sign up and earn Papa Rewards®️ Points on every order. Check out the latest offers and discounts on our online menu and order now from Papa Johns Sheffield - Ecclesall Road for delivery or collection.”
- Popular for lunch
- Popular for dinner
- Vegan options
- Vegetarian options
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Free street parking
- No-contact delivery
- Takeout
- Vegan options
- Casual
Show more amenities
- Onsite services
- Late-night food
- Dessert
- College students
- Offerings· 2
- Quick bite
- Vegetarian options
- Dining options· 2
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Service options· 1
- Delivery
Location
Pizza restaurants near Papa Johns Pizza
- Pizza BAR4.33700.5 mi
pizza, grilled chicken, donner and chips
- Proove Pizza4.51,1800.7 mi£10–20
stingy cheese and sauce toppings, vegan and gluten-free options, non-alcoholic cocktails
- Venice Pizza3.41540.7 mi
pizza, burgers, kebabs
| Place | Rating | Distance | Price | Mentioned in reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Papa Johns Pizza | 4.2814 | — | £10–20 | hand-tossed crust, vegan gluten-free pizza, chicken fajita pizza |
| Pizza BAR | 4.3370 | 0.5 mi | — | pizza, grilled chicken, donner and chips |
| Proove Pizza | 4.51,180 | 0.7 mi | £10–20 | stingy cheese and sauce toppings, vegan and gluten-free options, non-alcoholic cocktails |
| Venice Pizza | 3.4154 | 0.7 mi | — | pizza, burgers, kebabs |
The 3 nearest pizza restaurants by distance. Ratings, hours and review terms come from public business profiles.
Similar Pizza restaurants nearby
0.8 miRudy's Pizza Napoletana - Sheffield
3.1 miSunset Pizza
3.6 miUniversal Pizza & Burger Bar
3.8 miParkway Pizzeria
4.2 miTasty Bites
6.1 miMosborough Pizza & Kebab House
6.4 miPizza Lodge
6.4 miPrime Pizza Rotherham
More to explore in Sheffield

197 places
Restaurants in Sheffield
Photo: Turtle Bay Sheffield · 4.8 · 7,719 Google reviews
See all 197 restaurants in Sheffield
4.5 · Wonder KitchenChinese restaurants
42 places
4.5 · Forge Dam CafeCafes
77 places
4.6 · Rutland ArmsBars
75 places
4.5 · Beautiful NailsBeauty
12 places