
Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Sheffield
Quick info
About Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Sheffield
Rudy's Pizza Napoletana is a pizza restaurant in Sheffield, on Division St. The kitchen makes its dough on site every day and ferments it twice over 24 hours, so each pizza needs only 60 seconds in the oven. The menu includes a portobello pizza, with an nduja dip on the side for anyone who wants extra heat. Tiramisu is one of the desserts. The restaurant is walk-in, with seats at a pizza bar for guests who arrive without a reservation. From the seating area, diners can watch the pizzas being made.
Good to know
“For us it’s all about the pizza. Just like in Naples, our dough is made on site every day, takes 24 hours to double ferment and just 60 seconds to cook. It is soft, light and floppy… so fold for strength or tuck in with a knife and fork. Enjoy.”
- ReservationsWalk-in only
- AccessibilityWheelchair: entrance, restroom, seating
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention nduja dip, tiramisu, chilli honey dip and birthday desserts.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention nduja dip, tiramisu, chilli honey dip and birthday desserts.
Customer Review Summary
Pizza is the main draw, with reviewers calling it really tasty and huge, and one comparing it to pizza eaten in Venice. Diners name the portobello and pepperoni pizzas and a special regina. The dips earn their own praise: a thick, paste-like nduja dip and a chilli honey dip, alongside the garlic bread. Burrata and a cloudy apple and cherry drink get a mention, and one reviewer recommends the tiramisu, affogato and brownie with ice cream. Staff are described as friendly and quick, introducing themselves and checking in, and one reviewer likes that servers show their own personality through outfits. Another enjoys watching the pizzas being made from their seat. The main complaint comes from one diner without a reservation who was placed at the pizza bar and found the pizza watery with soggy dough. Another notes the only downside is too much choice. Several birthday visitors describe being acknowledged, one with a brownie and a tiramisu brought to the table.
Customer Review Summary
Pizza is the main draw, with reviewers calling it really tasty and huge, and one comparing it to pizza eaten in Venice. Diners name the portobello and pepperoni pizzas and a special regina. The dips earn their own praise: a thick, paste-like nduja dip and a chilli honey dip, alongside the garlic bread. Burrata and a cloudy apple and cherry drink get a mention, and one reviewer recommends the tiramisu, affogato and brownie with ice cream. Staff are described as friendly and quick, introducing themselves and checking in, and one reviewer likes that servers show their own personality through outfits. Another enjoys watching the pizzas being made from their seat. The main complaint comes from one diner without a reservation who was placed at the pizza bar and found the pizza watery with soggy dough. Another notes the only downside is too much choice. Several birthday visitors describe being acknowledged, one with a brownie and a tiramisu brought to the table.
Featured reviews
- Google user
“I just had a superb meal at this pizza spot and it never disappoints! The food was downright delicious, especially the garlic bread and the chilli honey dip – simply the best! The service was excellent too; the staff introduced themselves and checked in on us, making the whole experience feel personal. I can’t wait to return for more of those incredible flavours! Highly recommended for anyone looking for top-quality pizza!”
- Google user
“OK. Stop searching. I have done the hard work for you. You need the best pizza within 30 miles of Sheffield? You want the authentic pizza experience? You want great service and a relaxing vibe? Ruby's. Sorted. We had a wonderful time, and Faizan was the BEST server. The only downside? Lots, and lots, of choice”
- Google user
“I will preface this by saying this is the third time I eat at Rudy's. I find their menu has a good variety of options, also suitable for vegetarians, I also appreciate the specials that provide something new and different to try. The size of the pizzas is good and so are the flavours. I'm a big fan of their nduja dip, it has a thicker consistency, more like a paste, but it is hands down the best pizza dip I ever had. The staff is also very friendly. One thing I noticed is that the servers are allowed to show their own personality at work through their outfits and accessories. This is great and puts emphasis on a theme I've seen recently from Rudy's which is embracing the community and the people inside it. Attached is a picture of the nduja dip and their special regina pizza. Would visit again :)”
- Google user
“The staff were really nice and kind but placed us on the pizza bar instead of the table since we didn’t have a reservation, the pizza however did not taste nice as it was watery and the pizza dough was soggy. However the cloudy apple and cherry drink was amazing and the burrata was nice aswell. The pizza was the only issue.”
- Google user
“Quite nice restaurant. I really loved the portion size compared to the price. Very friendly staff. Clean and big public toilet upstairs. Overall really great experience. P.S. Tiramisu / Affogato / Brownie with ice cream, all highly recommended desserts.”
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Show more amenities
- Accessibility· 2
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Location
Pizza near Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Sheffield
- Sunset Pizza4.01023.6 mi
mixed grilled kebab, chicken shish special kebab, margherita pizza
- Tasty Bites3.9793.6 mi
donner meat pizza, chips, pizza
- Pizza Lodge3.7415.8 mi away
pizza, kebab, donner meat
| Place | Rating | Distance | Mentioned in reviews |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Sheffield | 4.81,412 | — | nduja dip, tiramisu, chilli honey dip |
| Sunset Pizza | 4.0102 | 3.6 mi | mixed grilled kebab, chicken shish special kebab, margherita pizza |
| Tasty Bites | 3.979 | 3.6 mi | donner meat pizza, chips, pizza |
| Pizza Lodge | 3.741 | 5.8 mi away | pizza, kebab, donner meat |
The 3 nearest pizza by distance. Ratings, hours and review terms come from public business profiles.
Similar Pizza nearby
More to explore in Sheffield

106 places
Restaurants in Sheffield
Photo: Himawari Sushi & Japanese Restaurant · 4.9 · 1,606 Google reviews
See all 106 restaurants in Sheffield



