Skip to main content
BusinessesMap
The Chubby Castor of the Fitzwilliam Arms — Restaurants in Peterborough

The Chubby Castor of the Fitzwilliam Arms

RestaurantsPeterborough

4.7 out of 5 stars4.7(262 reviews)

Advertisements

Quick info

020 8149 3777
34 Peterborough Rd, Peterborough, United Kingdom PE5 7AX

About The Chubby Castor of the Fitzwilliam Arms

The Chubby Castor of the Fitzwilliam Arms is a fine dining restaurant in the village of Castor, near Peterborough, housed in a thatched old pub building at 34 Peterborough Rd. The kitchen serves produce grown on its own grounds. Guests choose between an à la carte menu, a Daily Set Lunch and a seven-course tasting menu, and a wine pairing is available with the tasting menu. Scallops appear as a starter on the à la carte, and the 24-dish menu also lists carpaccio and cheeses. A plant-based three-course menu is offered for guests who want one, and a classic British Sunday Roast is on the menu too. Reservations are required. Dogs are welcome.

Good to know

  • Reservations
    Accepts reservations
  • Parking
    Free parking lot
  • Accessibility
    Wheelchair: entrance, parking lot, restroom, seating
  • Good for kids
    Good for kids · Has changing table(s) · High chairs
  • Dietary
    Organic dishes · Vegetarian options

Advertisements

Menu & Prices

24 dishes
  • Soup
  • Carpaccio
  • Salad
  • Carrot
  • Chocolate
  • Cheeses
See full menu & prices →

Reviews

4.7/5
262 reviews

What reviewers say

Reviewers most often mention scallops starter, seven-course tasting menu, à la carte menu and thatched building setting.

5★
220
4★
21
3★
8
2★
4
1★
9

Customer Review Summary

Diners most often single out the scallops on the à la carte menu, with the beef main and a fish dish also praised. Tasting menu fans name the crab lasagne, squab pigeon and lamb, plus the classic wine pairing. One birthday diner found the restaurant understaffed, with a waiter stretched thin and a waitress cold and impatient. Another had a birthday greeting arranged.

Featured reviews

  • Sebastian Melmoth
    “Chubby Castor – An Unforgettable Gastronomic Experience One of the finest culinary experiences of my life. Chubby Castor is an exceptional restaurant led by Chef Patron Ade Adeshina, originally from Nigeria, whose culinary journey has been influenced by two giants of international gastronomy: Gordon Ramsay and Marco Pierre White. Ade took over the Fitzwilliam Arms, a historic pub dating back approximately 400 years, located in the picturesque village of Castor, near Peterborough, transforming it into a highly prestigious gastronomic destination. The restaurant began its journey with the prestigious recognition of three AA Rosettes before subsequently attracting the attention of the Michelin Guide. The gastronomic offering includes a traditional à la carte menu, a Daily Set Lunch and the classic British Sunday Roast. However, to fully experience the chef's culinary philosophy, I chose the Signature Seven-Course Tasting Menu. A gastronomic journey through seven courses, where every dish tells a story of research, technique, creativity and distinctive personality. One of the most surprising moments of the tasting experience was a particular dish that I remember as a chicken preparation, possibly a Chicken Terrine with Ham Hock (although I would not want to misidentify it). Initially, it gave me a rather intense savoury sensation. Yet, as I continued tasting, something extraordinary happened: the salty flavour gradually transformed into something sweet, harmonious and delicate, eventually dissolving elegantly on the palate. It was a demonstration of how cooking can surprise and engage the senses through apparently contrasting sensations. To this day, I still cannot quite understand how such a transformation was possible! Also unforgettable were the Crab Lasagne, Squab Pigeon and Numark Lamb, three creations that demonstrated the chef's remarkable technical ability and creativity. The service was impeccable, attentive and professional, with every course accompanied by the appropriate care and sensitivity. At the end of the evening, I personally wanted to congratulate Ade and his team, thanking them for giving me such a special experience, together with all the front-of-house staff who contributed to making the evening so memorable. As a hospitality professional, with many years spent working in restaurants, hotels and international establishments across Greece, Thailand, the United Kingdom, America, France and Italy, I know how to recognise when a gastronomic experience is built around a genuine philosophy rather than simply the preparation of excellent food. Unfortunately, for health reasons, I have never had the opportunity to return, but it remains one of those memories I treasure with particular affection. Because great cuisine is not simply about satisfying the palate. It is about creating emotions, leaving lasting memories and telling a story through every single dish. As an Italian, I would never have imagined that Nigeria could produce talents of this extraordinary calibre. Once again, I would like to thank the Chef for making me realise that genius and creativity have no nationality, no colours, no political or religious affiliation. They belong only to the touch of genius that brings an individual's vision of a dish to life. Thank you, Chubby Castor, for teaching us what the right vision of gastronomy truly means. SM & Giovanni Restaurant Manager – The Lakes Restaurant, Burgh le Marsh, UK Convivium Restaurant – Santorini”
  • Ahnnoi Naja
    “We visited this Michelin-starred restaurant to celebrate my friend's birthday, and I have to say — the food was fantastic. Beautifully presented, full of flavour, and clearly made with skill and care. The kitchen team truly deserves the star, and we really enjoyed every dish. That said, considering we paid over £200 for the meal, the service didn't quite match the standard we expected — especially compared to other Michelin-starred places we've been to. There was one male waiter who was clearly doing his best — polite, professional, and working hard — but he was stretched too thin. The restaurant seemed understaffed, and he couldn't give us the attention we would have liked. That wasn't his fault at all; he genuinely tried. Unfortunately, the female waitress we dealt with came across as quite cold and impatient. She seemed rushed and a little dismissive, which was disappointing for a special occasion. Even though we said thank you every single time, she never once said thank you back. At times, it felt like we were being an inconvenience rather than guests celebrating a birthday. We've been lucky enough to visit several Michelin-starred restaurants before, and the service has always been warm and welcoming — so this experience stood out for the wrong reasons. I hope the management can look into staffing and training, because the food here really deserves to be matched by the front-of-house. All in all, a brilliant meal, but the service left us a little disappointed.”
  • Suzanne Barber
    “Went for a special birthday lunch and sample the à la carte menu. The scallops were to die for, the fish dish was just perfect and the staff were friendly without being overly formal. Definitely plan to return to have the taster menu and wine flight in the near future.”
  • Mark Armstrong
    “I took my mother here to celebrate her 90th birthday. What an exceptionally wonderful restaurant and located near Peterborough of all things. This is a Michelin level restaurant and for a reason. Their menu is exceptional. Location is a beautiful old thatched building and easy to get to. Staff were professional and efficient. Highly recommend this fine restaurant.”
  • Ross Stevens
    “An absolutely fantastic experience in every way. Each course was delicious, far exceeding our expectations, and the surprise dishes brought out in-between courses topped off a lovely dining experience. Everything we ate was faultless in both presentation and flavour. We were served the 3-course plant-based menu by Gina who was friendly, approachable, and informative from the minute we sat down. She was also happy to arrange a little something to wish a "Happy Birthday" to my partner which topped off a wonderful evening. Having never tried a restaurant of this calibre before, I was initially quite skeptical beforehand. But having experienced the brilliant service and delicious food, I wouldn't hesitate to return and to recommend this restaurant to family & friends.”

Hours

Monday
Closed
Tuesday
Closed
Wednesday
,
Thursday
,
Friday
,
Saturday
,
Sunday

Highlights

  • Great coffee
  • Great dessert
  • Great wine list
  • Popular for lunch
  • Popular for dinner
  • Popular for solo dining

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Accepts reservations
  • Outdoor seating
  • Dogs allowed
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
Show more amenities
  • Dine-in
  • Family-friendly
  • Vegetarian options
  • Bar onsite
  • Cozy
  • Beer
Offerings· 8
  • Alcohol
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Free water refills
  • Hard liquor
  • Healthy options
  • Organic dishes
  • Wine
Facilities· 1
  • Restroom
Accessibility· 3
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
Dining options· 5
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Catering
  • Dessert
  • Table service
Highlights· 3
  • Great coffee
  • Great dessert
  • Great wine list
Crowd· 1
  • Groups
Planning· 3
  • Lunch reservations recommended
  • Reservations required
  • Dinner reservations recommended
Popular for· 1
  • Solo dining
Atmosphere· 4
  • Historic
  • Romantic
  • Trendy
  • Upscale
Parking· 1
  • Free parking lot
Family-friendly· 4
  • Good for kids
  • Has changing table(s)
  • High chairs
  • Kids' menu
Pet-friendly· 2
  • Dogs allowed inside
  • Dogs allowed outside

Location

Restaurants near The Chubby Castor of the Fitzwilliam Arms

The Chubby Castor of the Fitzwilliam Arms
Outdoor seatingVegetarian optionsWheelchair accessible
4.7262
  • 3 mi

    5 course tasting menu, dishes introduced by chefs, wine flight pairing

  • Megabite4.1350
    4.2 mi£1–20Wheelchair accessibleGood for kidsReservations

    spicy chicken, donner kebab, chicken tikka

  • 4.2 mi£1–10

    chicken shawarma wrap, lentil soup, fresh naan

The 3 nearest restaurants by distance. Ratings, hours and review terms come from public business profiles.

More to explore in Peterborough

Turtle Bay Peterborough, Peterborough

39 places

Restaurants in Peterborough

Photo: Turtle Bay Peterborough · 4.8 · 11,708 Google reviews

See all 39 restaurants in Peterborough
  • The Fitzwilliam Arms, Peterborough

    Bars

    11 places in Peterborough

    Photo: The Fitzwilliam Arms · 4.6 · 3,057 reviews

DirectionsCallMenu