Pizza on the Square

Featured reviews

• M

  Mark Proctor

  ·1 month ago

  “My wife and I were here in August. It wasn't busy but there was a good atmosphere and the staff were very helpful. Unfortunately we had to send our pizza back BUT the replacement pizza was absolutely delicious! No complaints, we were treated very well. Great service, great quality and options, well worth a visit!”

• N

  Neel Robb

  ·1 month ago

  “Great pizza and a pint deal on weekdays. Bargain and excellent pizza. Paper plates are fine and make sense.”

• V

  Vicki

  ·2 months ago

  “Pizza was nothing special and served on paper plates. Chicken parm sandwich was bland and the focaccia it was served on was badly cut so only half was actually a sandwich and half burnt + missing filling from the menu description. Side salad was barely there and not very fresh. Plenty of chips with the sandwich though. 3 staff on the bar, only one seemed to do any work the others were too busy flirting. In all honesty, wouldn't return.”

  Read more
• D

  Dean Wyatt

  ·3 months ago

  “Top quality pizza, had the puttanesca one which was delicious if you like savoury salty goodness and okay with anchovies. Rosemary garlic bread really good too. Went with my rather neurospicy family and staff were very understanding and helpful, facilitated moving tables when we needed to (brother is wary around dogs). Nice chill vibe, got us all round a table and relaxing atmosphere helped smoothed tensions after a heatwave day of chaos. Can’t thank the crew enough for being nice and welcoming to us all. Seriously good pizza!”

  Read more
• J

  Jessica C

  ·5 months ago

  “The pizzas were absolutely beautiful and full of flavour, and the building itself is stunning—such a lovely place to sit and eat. It’s just a shame that the overall experience didn’t quite match the quality of the food. We had to wait over an hour for our pizzas, despite it not seeming overly busy, and we weren’t informed in advance that there would be such a long delay. We even overheard another customer raising the same concern, so it clearly wasn’t just us. When the first two pizzas arrived (on paper plates too), we then had to wait a further six minutes for the remaining two. By that point, the children were already halfway through theirs, which made it difficult to enjoy the meal together as a family. Customer service could also be improved. There wasn’t much communication or updates from staff, and I had to go up myself to ask where our food was. Overall, the food and venue have so much potential, it’s dog friendly (cool stone floor which our dog loved) but the service and kitchen efficiency need to be reviewed to better handle demand. With some improvements, this could easily be a fantastic dining experience.”

  Read more

• T

  Tommy Asso

  ·6 months ago

  “Very good beer and very good food, can be very busy but well worth a visit”

• L

  L T

  ·7 months ago

  “Friendly helpful staff. Gluten free menu also available. Good size portions. Easy to get a table. But for food we picked and how many people in at time we were there, was a 20 minutes wait, but well worth it.”

• M

  Madeleine Kinghorn

  ·9 months ago

  “The pizzas are nice when they finally arrive but a 45 minute wait for two pizzas is too much, especially when there were lots of empty tables so it wasn’t busy. All the other tables were waiting too, so it wasn’t just us. We were also a bit surprised that everything is served on paper plates. I’m all in favour of compostable plates, but not if they stick to your food. I don’t expect to peel paper off my pizza before I can eat it. On the plus side, it’s dog friendly and was very quiet so we got a table easily.”

  Read more
• T

  Timmy Wilkinson

  ·3 years ago

  “We stopped here for lunch while our car was changing. What a great location! And the building itself is really nice too. I'm not sure what it used to be, maybe a council building? Lots of character! They had plenty of tables available and more seating upstairs, also the menu looked great, who doesn't like pizza! Plus VEGAN cheese options!! It's order at the bar, and they have a large variety of drinks on offer. We unfortunately got charged extra for our meals but that was sorted out because of miscommunication from the staff. The food was about 20mins wait which wasn't too bad. Nice fresh ingredients, the sauce on the pizza was excellent too. The chips were really hot and crispy too. I would recommend this place if you're in and around Malton.”

  Read more
• P

  Poppy Runi

  ·3 years ago

  “Great vibes and great food! I had the margarita pizza which was super cheesy and filling, the chips as well were very crispy and good value for portion! The staff were very friendly and the service was great! Definitely would go again ✨”