
American restaurant
Croton Reservoir Tavern Menu & Prices — New York
108 W 40th St, New York
- Rating
- 4.3 ★786 reviews
- Open now
- Closed
Menu
Menu sectionSHAREABLES
BURGERS3 dishes
- CROTON BURGER$24.00
Gorgonzola, shredded romaine, roasted garlic crema, brioche bun
- TAVERN BURGER$22.00
White cheddar, shredded lettuce, tomato, brioche bun
- VEGGIE BURGER$20.00
Jalapenos, grilled red onion, tomato jam, shredded romaine, roasted garlic crema, onion roll
Advertisements
GARDEN GREENS & BOWLS5 dishes
- THE COBB$21.00
Mesclun, grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, blue cheese, egg, avocado, tomato, herb vinaigrette
- ALL HAIL CAESAR$16.00
Romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons, Caesar dressing
- GREEN GODDESS$18.00
Baby gem lettuce, shaved brussels sprouts, red cabbage, roasted caramelized carrots, sunflower seeds, green goddess dressing
- AHI TUNA BOWL$30.00
Sriracha tuna, cucumber, edamame, pickled onion, mango, crispy onions, sticky rice, furikake
- MEDITERRANEAN BOWL$20.00
Chopped romaine, cucumber, tomato, pickled red onion, chickpeas, kalamata olives, sticky rice, feta, herb dressing
TACOS AND FLATBREADS6 dishes
- BRISKET TACOS$18.00
Pickled onion, tomatillo sauce, cilantro
- CHICKEN TACOS$16.00
Braised chicken, pickled onion, tomatillo sauce, cilantro
- PORK CARNITAS TACOS$16.00
Pulled pork with slaw, pickled onions, cilantro, tomatillo sauce
- ROASTED GARLIC FLATBREAD$18.00
Spicy yogurt sauce, roasted mushrooms, garlic puree, herb pesto, everything bagel seasoning
- MARGHERITA FLATBREAD$19.00
Plum tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil, EVOO
- SHORT RIB FLATBREAD$21.00
Housemade spicy red sauce, burrata, fresh tomato, red onion, basil, EVOO
HANDHELDS5 dishes
- BEER BELLY PULLED PORK$20.00
Bourbon BBQ, slaw, pickles, brioche bun
- CROTON CRUNCH$23.00
Spicy fried chicken, house chili onion crunch, slaw, pickles, brioche bun
- GRILLED CHEESE AND TOMATO BISQUE$22.00
Toasted country bread, pepper jack cheese, cheddar cheese, tomato bisque
- BRAISED BRISKET$23.00
Onion, cheddar cheese, bacon, jalapeños, yogurt spread, toasted sourdough, jus
- GRILLED CHICKEN WRAP$21.00
Herb-marinated chicken, bacon, avocado, Swiss cheese, shredded romaine, tomato, house chipotle ranch, whole wheat wrap
ENTREES5 dishes
- CRISPY SKIN SALMON$36.00
Ancient grains, braised greens, apple butter, herb salad
- STEAK FRITES$39.00
Grilled hanger steak, hand-cut fries, roasted shallot red wine demi-glace
- ROAST CHICKEN$31.00
Pastrami-spiced roasted chicken, served with whipped potatoes, sautéed broccolini, and natural chicken jus
- WILD MUSHROOM RAVIOLI$29.00
Cheese ravioli, oyster mushrooms, sweet peas, white wine parmesan cream sauce
- RIBEYE$51.00
16oz bone-in ribeye, brown butter carrot puree, wild mushrooms, pearl onions
SLIDERS3 dishes
- BEEF$18.00
Cheddar, tomato, pickle
- PULLED PORK$18.00
Slaw
- VEGGIE$18.00
Tomato jam, romaine, roasted garlic crema
Advertisements
SOUPS AND SIDES6 dishes
- TOMATO BISQUE$12.00
Please ask your server about our soup special
- BASKET OF SWEET POTATO FRIES$12.00
- BASKET OF HAND CUT FRIES$11.00
- MASHED POTATOES$10.00
- SAUTEED BROCCOLINI$10.00
- SIDE SALAD$10.00
THREE-COURSE ~ PRE-THEATER1 dish
- THREE-COURSE ~ PRE-THEATER
ACT ONE4 dishes
- ALL HAIL CAESAR
Romaine lettuce with croutons tossed in our Caesar dressing and topped with shredded parmesan cheese
- CRISPY BRUSSELS
Whipped feta, pickled shallots, candied pecans, hot honey
- HUMMUS
EVOO garlic, onion, pico de gallo, house pita
- TOMATO BISQUE
ACT TWO5 dishes
- CROTON BURGER
Gorgonzola, shredded romaine, roasted garlic crema, brioche bun
- CRISPY SKIN SALMON
Ancient grains, braised greens, apple butter, herb salad
- STEAK FRITES$8.00
Grilled hanger, house fries, roasted shallot red wine demi
- WILD MUSHROOM RAVIOLI
Cheese ravioli, oyster mushrooms, sweet peas, white wine parmesan cream sauce
- ROAST CHICKEN
Pastrami-spiced chicken, whipped potatoes, sautéed broccolini, chicken jus
FINALE2 dishes
- CARAMEL APPLE CHEESECAKE
- CHOCOLATE FUDGE CAKE
HAPPY HOUR10 dishes
- MANGO HABANERO MARGARITA$12.00
- CLASSIC MARGARITA$10.00
- OLD FASHIONED$12.00
- MANHATTAN$12.00
- SANGRIA$10.00
- COSMOPOLITAN$12.00
- APEROL SPRITZ$12.00
- SELECT WINES$10.00
Cabernet, sauvignon blanc
- DRAFT BEER$2.00
Off normal price
- WELL DRINKS$10.00
For the Group6 dishes
- Bang Bang$16.00
Szechuan style cauliflower, sesame seed, green onion, Thai bird chili
- Wings (10)$17.00
Choice of house-made buffalo, BBQ or 50/50 sauce with blue cheese
- Return Of The Mac$16.00
Shells, cheddar, gouda, jack, garlic breadcrumbs. Chicken +9, steak +14, shrimp +12
- Hummus$16.00
Harissa, EVOO, garlic, onion, pico de gallo, house pita
- Avocado Toast$17.00
Avocado, cherry tomatoes, pickled red onion, small salad. Add poached egg +5 | Add smoked salmon +9
- NYC Mega Pretzel$16.00
Stone ground mustard, beer
Breakfast10 dishes
- Cinnamon French Toast$21.00
Cinnamon cream cheese frosting
- Lemon Ricotta Pancakes$21.00
Berry and bourbon compote
- NYC Tavern Omelet$22.00
Peppers, caramelized onions, cheddar cheese, with breakfast potatoes
- White Omelet$22.00
Roast tomato, spinach, feta, side salad
- Chicken and Waffles$22.00
Chicken and cheddar and jalapeño waffle, hot honey glazed popcorn chicken
- Steak and Eggs$39.00
Two eggs any style, hanger steak, breakfast potatoes
- Bryant Park Breakfast$23.00
Two eggs any style, choice of ham, sausage patties or bacon, breakfast potatoes, toast
- BEC (NYC Classic)$18.00
Bacon, egg with cheddar cheese, toasted brioche
- Breakfast Burrito$19.00
Cheddar cheese, sausage patties, breakfast potatoes, scrambled eggs, sour cream, pico de gallo, whole wheat wrap
- Salmon Benedict$23.00
Smoked salmon, hollandaise sauce, served with mixed green salad
Handhelds4 dishes
- Croton Burger$23.00
Gorgonzola, shredded romaine, roasted garlic aioli, brioche bun
- NYC Tavern Burger$21.00
White cheddar, shredded lettuce, tomato, brioche bun
- Croton Crunch$22.00
Spicy fried chicken, house dill onion, crunch slaw, pickles, brioche
- Grilled Chicken Wrap$20.00
Herb marinated chicken, bacon, avocado, Swiss cheese, shredded romaine, tomato, house chipotle ranch, whole wheat wrap
Garden & Greens4 dishes
- Spicy Caesar$16.00
Romaine, shaved parmesan, anchovy, spicy Caesar dressing, toasted lemon bread crumb
- Green Goddess$17.00
Romaine, shaved Brussels sprouts, red cabbage, roasted caramelized carrots, green goddess dressing
- Ahi Tuna Bowl$30.00
Sriracha tuna, cucumber, edamame, pickled onion, mango, crispy onions, sticky rice, furikake
- Mediterranean Bowl$19.00
Chopped romaine, cucumber, tomato, pickled red onion, chickpeas, kalamata olives, sticky rice, feta and herb dressing
Side5 dishes
- Bacon$8.00
- Sausage$8.00
- Ham$6.00
- Basket of Fries$11.00
- Breakfast Potatoes$9.00
SIGNATURES8 dishes
- CROTON MILK PUNCH$19.00
Bourbon, black tea, lemon, pineapple, spices, clarified milk
- MANGO HABANERO MARGARITA$18.00
Croton tequila, mango, habanero tincture, lime juice
- THE RESERVOIR SOUR$18.00
Rye, blackberry shrub, lemon
- PASSIONFRUIT SMOKE$19.00
Vanilla vodka, passionfruit, lemon, egg white, smoked rosemary
- STRAWBERRY CLOUD$19.00
Vodka, strawberry, elderflower, lemon, foam
- LAVENDER HAZE$18.00
Lavender infused vodka, Italicus, simple syrup, lime juice
- BOURBON SMASH$18.00
Bourbon, blackberry, coconut, mint
- PASSION PIT$18.00
Croton vodka, passionfruit, pineapple juice, lemon juice
DRAFT COCKTAILS2 dishes
- JIM BEAM & LEMONADE$14.00
- HORNITOS MEXICAN MULE$17.00
SPRITZ5 dishes
- THE CROTON SUNSET$18.00
Dark rum, rose, Campari, passionfruit, and soda
- HUGO SPRITZ$18.00
Elderflower, prosecco, mint, and lime
- SARTI SPRITZ$19.00
Sarti Aperitif, Prosecco, and soda
- ALOE AFTERGLOW$19.00
Mezcal-infused limoncello, aloe liqueur, prosecco, and soda
- STRAWBERRY-RHUBARB SPRITZ$18.00
Vodka, strawberry-rhubarb shrub, prosecco, and soda
MARTINIS5 dishes
- THE 40TH STREET VESPER$20.00
Gin, vodka, Cocchi Americano, and lemon oil
- ESPRESSO MARTINI$19.00
Vodka, cold brew, coffee liqueur, vanilla, and sea salt
- THE DIRTY$19.00
Vodka or gin with house brine, shaken cold
- TRUFFLE SHUFFLE MARTIN$21.00
Vodka, olive brine, and truffle oil
- GIBSON$19.00
Gin, fino sherry, pickled onion brine, and rosemary
Croton Reservoir Tavern: opening hours, photos and reviews →
More menus nearby
Beyond Sushi Vegan Restaurant0.2 mi · ★ 4.6 · Vegan restaurant129 dishesMenu
Amor Loco0.3 mi · ★ 4.7 · Mexican restaurant49 dishesMenu
Blue Fin0.4 mi · ★ 4.2 · Seafood restaurant53 dishesMenu
Ane American Bar & Grill0.4 mi · ★ 4.6 · American restaurant77 dishesMenu
Buena Vista Restaurant & Bar0.5 mi · ★ 4.7 · Bar & grill93 dishesMenu
Ammos Estiatorio0.5 mi · ★ 4.1 · Greek restaurant58 dishesMenu