
Italian restaurant
Brewster's New Buffalo Menu & Prices
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
- Rating
- 4.6 ★2,074 reviews
- Open now
- Closed
Menu
Menu sectionOTHER BEV
OTHER BEV22 dishes
- Acqua Panna Still Water$8.00
- Arnold Palmer$4.00
- Casa Mara Soda$8.00
- Fever Tree$8.00
- Flavored Pelligrino$5.00
blood orange or limonata
- Fresh Squeezed OJ$6.00
- Ginger Beer$4.00
- Gingergrass Cbd$8.00
- Iced Tea$4.00
- Italian Soda$5.00
- Juices$4.00
orange, cranberry, or apple
- Kids Bev$4.00
- Large AquaPanna$7.00
- Large Milk$4.00
- Lavender Lemonade$6.00
- Lemonade$4.00
- Raspberry Lemonade$6.00
- San Pellegrino$5.00
italian natural mineral water 16oz
- Small Milk$3.00
- Soda$4.00
coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, lemonade, ginger ale, soda water, tonic water, iced tea
- Strawberry Lemonade$6.00
- Tonic$3.00
BREAKFAST ENTREES12 dishes
- Avocado Toast$15.00
spiced avocado mousse, spinach and tomato bruschetta topped with two over-easy eggs on thick cut sourdough drizzled with balsamic reduction
- Berry Pancakes$14.00
stack of 3 pancakes with our homemade berry sauce
- Biscuits And Gravy
biscuits and sausage gravy finished with scallions
- Breakfast BLT$16.00
smoked bacon, lettuce, roma tomato and garlic aioli with two over-easy eggs on sun-dried tomato focaccia, served with potatoes
- Hippie Hash$13.00
onion, roasted garlic, roasted red pepper, mushroom, spinach, potato and fresh herb with roasted garlic oil and a side of toast
- Mary's Mess$22.00
"the mess" with a brewster's bloody mary
- Mascarpone - Stuffed French Toast$17.00
brioche dipped in custard, layered with mascarpone topped with our homemade berry sauce and powdered sugar
- Pancakes$12.00
stack of 3 served w/ pure maple syrup
- Regular French Toast$12.00
- The Mess$17.00
our house specialty scramble w/ cheddar cheese + bacon + onion + roasted red peppers + potatoes + eggs + roasted garlic + sausage w/ a biscuit no substitutions*
- The Old Standby
two eggs to order, potato, choice of bacon or sausage patty and a biscuit
- Breakfast Feature$16.00
Advertisements
A LA CARTE11 dishes
- Bacon$4.00
two strips
- (2 ) Eggs
two cooked to order
- Sausage$3.00
two links
- Biscuit$2.00
served w/ dara's homemade jam
- SD Of Hippie Hash$8.00
onion, roasted garlic, roasted red pepper, mushroom, spinach, potato and fresh herb with roasted garlic oil and a side of toast
- SD Potatoes$4.00
diced and seasoned
- Side Of Gravy$3.00
- Single Pancake$4.00
served with pure maple syrup
- Toast W Jam$2.00
- Fruit Bowl$5.00
- Cinnamon Roll$8.00
KIDS BREAKFAST4 dishes
- Kids Berry Pancakes$7.00
served with our homemade berry sauce
- Kids Egg Breakfast$5.00
two eggs scrambled with cheddar cheese and a biscuit
- Kids Pancakes$5.00
served with maple syrup
- Kids French Toast$7.00
served with maple syrup
12” SOURDOUGH PIES4 dishes
- 12” Betty White$17.00
garlic confit, creamy fontina, pecorino, rosemary ricotta and hot honey on roasted garlic oil
- 12” New Yorker$18.00
fontina + provolone + mozzarella + pizza sauce + finished w /shaved pecorino + dry oregano + crushed chilis + garlic oil
- 12” Sweet + Spicy$20.00
cup n' char pepperoni + calabrian chili's + deli pepperoni + fresh mozzarella + crushed tomato base + basil drizzled w/ spicy honey + reggiano *SF
- Pizza Time$19.00
12” THIN CRUST SPECIAL PIES4 dishes
- 12” Bianco$18.00
roasted garlic + spinach + ricotta + sausage + fontina + reggiano + e.v.o.o. base
- 12” Fungi$18.00
garlic, roasted mushroom, sausage, fresh oregano and ricotta on an evoo base topped with truffle oil
- 12” Marg Pie$18.00
roma tomato, garlic, basil, fresh mozzarella, reggiano and pinenuts
- 12” Quattro Formaggi$16.00
aged gorgonzola + house cheese + provolone + mozzarella + pesto base
14" SD CRUST SPECIAL PIES7 dishes
- 14" Margherita$22.00
roma tomato, garlic, basil, fresh mozzarella, reggiano and pinenuts
- 14" Quattro Formaggi$21.00
aged gorgonzola + house cheese + provolone + mozzarella + pesto base
- 14” Betty White$24.00
garlic confit, creamy fontina, pecorino, rosemary ricotta and hot honey on roasted garlic oil
- 14” Bianco$20.00
roasted garlic + spinach + ricotta + sausage + fontina + reggiano + e.v.o.o. base
- 14” Funghi$22.00
garlic, roasted mushroom, sausage, fresh oregano and ricotta on an evoo base topped with truffle oil
- 14” New Yorker$21.00
fontina + provolone + mozzarella + pizza sauce + finished w /shaved pecorino + dry oregano + crushed chilis + garlic oil
- 14” Sweet & Spicy$23.00
cup n' char pepperoni + calabrian chili's + deli pepperoni + fresh mozzarella + crushed tomato base + basil drizzled w/ spicy honey + reggiano *SF
Advertisements
BYO 5", 12” Pizza2 dishes
- 12” BYO Pizza$16.00
WITH ANY TWO REGULAR TOPPINGS - 12 {includes pizza cheese} choose your crust/pick a base/regular toppings 2.00 each/special toppings 3.00 each
- 5" Pizza
with any two toppings (thin crust only) served with house salad or soup
BYO 14" & Large Detroit2 dishes
- 14" BYO Pizza$20.00
build your 14" sourdough pizza choose base plus 2 regular toppings all pizzas come with cheese
- Large BYO Detroit$32.00
BYO large detroit style pizza choose pesto or red sauce and 2 regular toppings all pizzas include cheese
Classic Coffees6 dishes
- Hot Tea$3.00
japanese sencha green tea, english breakfast tea, raspberry decaf tea, cinnamon spice black tea, herbal decaf ceylon black tea, + earl grey
- Med Coffee$4.00
- Mocha$6.00
- Cappuccino$5.00
- Espresso$3.00
- Latte$5.00
LUNCH CLASSICS *served with house salad or soup11 dishes
- Cacio E Pepe
black pepper + parmesan + linguini + scarpetta/add chicken 3 / add shrimp 8 / gluten free pasta 3
- Chicken Alfredo
baby spinach + roasted red peppers + parmesan cream sauce tossed w/ pappardelle finished w/ reggiano/add chicken 3 / add shrimp 8 / gluten free pasta 3
- Meatballs
house-made marinara + ground beef and pork meatballs + long pasta/add chicken 3 / add shrimp 8 / gluten free pasta 3
- Roma
tri-color cheese filled tortellini sautéed in e.v.o.o. + roma tomatoes + basil + garlic + reggiano/add chicken 3 / add shrimp 8 / gluten free pasta 3
- Lobster Pomodoro
- Shrimp Alfredo
baby spinach + roasted red peppers + parmesan cream sauce tossed w/ pappardelle finished w/ reggiano/add chicken 3 / add shrimp 8 / gluten free pasta 3
- Tikka Masala
rich tomato and butter sauce+ curry spiced chicken + lime basmati rice+ cilantro +sweet pomegranate crema
- Lunch Feature
- Lemon Basil Chicken
- Veal Bolognese
- Shrimp And Sausage
REFRESHMENTS9 dishes
- Acqua Panna Still Water$8.00
- Flavored Pelligrino$5.00
blood orange or limonata
- Strawberry Lemonade$5.00
- Juices$4.00
orange, cranberry, or apple
- Lavender Lemonade$6.00
- Raspberry Lemonade$6.00
- San Pellegrino$5.00
italian natural mineral water 16oz
- Soda$4.00
coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, lemonade, ginger ale, soda water, tonic water, iced tea
- Topo Chico$5.00
Topo Chico has always been known for the legend surrounding its origins. Whether you believe in the legend or not, you'll still be able to enjoy the crisp, no-calorie taste of Topo Chico.
SALADS20 dishes
- $Balsamic$$0.75
- $Dressing$$0.75
- $Gorg$$1.00
- 1/2 Chopped Salad + Soup$15.00
- 1/2 Chopped Salad Solo$10.00
- 1/2 Specialty Salad + Soup$18.00
- 1/2 Specialty Salad Solo$11.00
- 1/2 Steak Salad + Soup$16.00
- 1/2 Steak Salad Solo$11.00
- Chopped Margherita$17.00
chopped lettuce + tomatoes + fresh mozzarella + olives + red onion topped w/ basil + reggiano + pine nuts + balsamic reduction
- Double House$14.00
- House Salad$7.00
mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan † our creamy balsamic dressing
- House Salad + Soup$12.00
mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan + our creamy balsamic dressing
- Rustic Steak Salad$21.00
sautéed beef tips served medium rare + bed of mixed greens + roasted potatoes + mushrooms + onions + melted gorgonzola creamy tarragon dressing
- Hot Soup$5.00
- Hot Soup Quart$15.00
- Specialty Salad$22.00
seared salmon + turkish apricots + almonds + chevre + cherry tomatoes + mixed greens + honey dijon vinaigrette
- Wedge$17.00
- Caesar$15.00
- Salad Spec$17.00
SANDWICHES5 dishes
- Brewster's Nightclub
- Chicken Schnitzel Sandwich
crispy fried chicken, avocado mayo, shredded napa cabbage, smoked gouda, bacon and mustard pickled onions finished with a hot honey glaze on toasted ciabatta served with salad or soup
- Double Smashburger$19.00
blend of short rib, brisket and ground chuck smashed thin with red onion and american cheese served with tater tots and awesome sauce
- Smoked Turkey Sandwich
turkey w/ our house made basil pesto + creamy fontina cheese + roma tomatoes on hearth baked sourdough *add bacon 2 served with salad or soup
- Lunch Sando
SMALL SPECIAL DETROITS1 dish
- Small Triple Crown$28.00
Grande and cup-n-char pepperoni, Wisconsin brick and white cheddar cheeses on a crispy and chewy crust topped with mozzarella, basil, hot honey and crushed red tomato sauce
Specialty Coffees7 dishes
- Chai Tea Latte$5.00
- Golden Latte$6.00
golden milk (turmeric infused milk), espresso, honey, + cinnamon
- Hot Chocolate$5.00
home-made steamed chocolate milk
- Glacier Cappuccino$6.00
- Lavender Latte$6.00
lavender tea latte
- Salted Caramel White Chocolate Mocha$6.00
- Warm Hug$6.00
cinnamon + carmel latte
STARTERS10 dishes
- Bruschetta$18.00
roma tomatoes + red onion + basil + e.v.o.o. + reggiano aged balsamic reduction w/ crostini
- Extra Bread$2.00
- Flatbread$5.00
- Olives And Feta$18.00
- Spinach + Artichoke Dip$16.00
served w/ rustic flatbread
- NAAN Bread$3.00
- Autumn Crudo$19.00
- Pears And Cheese$13.00
- Blueberries And Brussels Sprouts$16.00
- Watermelon Tomato$16.00
BYO SMALL DETROITS1 dish
- SMALL BYO DETROIT$23.00
choose pesto or red sauce (comes on top) choose two regular toppings (all pizzas include cheese)
12” SOURDOUGH PIES3 dishes
- 12” BETTY WHITE$18.00
garlic confit, fresh mozzarella, creamy fontina, pecorino, rosemary ricotta and hot honey on a parmesan crust
- 12” New Yorker$18.00
fontina + provolone + mozzarella + pizza sauce + finished w /shaved pecorino + dry oregano + crushed chilis + garlic oil
- 12” Sweet + Spicy$20.00
cup n' char pepperoni + calabrian chili's + deli pepperoni + fresh mozzarella + crushed tomato base + basil drizzled w/ spicy honey + reggiano *SF
12” THIN CRUST SPECIAL PIES4 dishes
- 12” Bianco$18.00
roasted garlic + spinach + ricotta + sausage + fontina + reggiano + e.v.o.o. base
- 12” Fungi$18.00
garlic, roasted mushroom, sausage, fresh oregano and ricotta on an evoo base topped with truffle oil
- 12” Marg Pie$18.00
- 12” Quattro Formaggi$16.00
aged gorgonzola + house cheese + provolone + mozzarella + pesto base
BYO 12”1 dish
- 12” BYO Pizza$16.00
WITH ANY TWO REGULAR TOPPINGS - 12 {includes pizza cheese} choose your crust/pick a base/regular toppings 2.00 each/special toppings 3.00 each
DINNER PASTA7 dishes
- Cacio E Pepe$26.00
black pepper + parmesan + pecorino + linguini + scarpetta
- Chicken Alfredo$31.00
baby spinach + roasted red peppers + parmesan cream sauce tossed w/ pappardelle + reggiano
- Lemon Basil Chicken$31.00
- Lobster Pomodoro$35.00
- Meatballs$29.00
house-made marinara + ground beef and pork meatballs + long pasta
- Roma$28.00
tri-color cheese filled tortellini sautéed in e.v.o.o. + roma tomatoes + basil + garlic + reggiano
- Shrimp Alfredo$31.00
baby spinach, roasted pepper and parmesan cream sauce tossed with herb pappardelle and reggiano
DINNER ENTREES7 dishes
- Autumn Bourride$35.00
- DINNER FEATURE$35.00
- Halibut And Succotash$47.00
- New York Strip$45.00
- Short Rib & Hummus$31.00
sumac braised short rib with roasted garlic hummus, pomegranate molasses, red onion and mint
- Tikka Masala$31.00
- Special Smash Burger$24.00
DINNER SALADS14 dishes
- Chopped Margherita$17.00
chopped lettuce + tomatoes + fresh mozzarella + olives + red onion topped w/ basil + reggiano + pine nuts + balsamic reduction
- Double House$14.00
- Dressing$0.75
- Extra Bread$2.00
- Wedge Salad$17.00
- Hot Soup$5.00
- Hot Soup Quart$15.00
- House Salad$7.00
mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan † our creamy balsamic dressing
- Rustic Steak Salad$21.00
sautéed beef tips served medium rare + bed of mixed greens + roasted potatoes + mushrooms + onions + melted gorgonzola creamy tarragon dressing
- Specialty Salad$22.00
seared salmon + turkish apricots + almonds + chevre + cherry tomatoes + mixed greens + honey dijon vinaigrette
- 1/2 Chop Solo$8.00
- Caesar$18.00
- Crispy Chicken$7.00
- GAZ BOWL$5.00
DINNER STARTERS8 dishes
- Blueberries And Brussel Sprouts$16.00
- Bruschetta$18.00
roma tomatoes + red onion + basil + e.v.o.o. + reggiano aged balsamic reduction w/ crostini
- Flatbread$5.00
- NAAN Bread$3.00
- Olives And Feta$18.00
- Special App Lettuces$19.00
- Spinach + Artichoke Dip$16.00
served w/ rustic flatbread
- For TheTable$13.00
KIDS PIZZA1 dish
- KIDS 5" BYO PIZZA$6.00
5" cheese and one topping - choose your base: tomato sauce, pesto or olive oil
KIDS PASTA2 dishes
- Kids Pasta Of The Day
chef's choice of pasta w/ your choice (1) sauce: marinara, olive oil, butter or cheese sauce
- Kids Roma$7.00
tri-color tortellini tossed in garlic oil w/ roma tomatoes, basil & reggiano cheese $3 per meatball / $3 chicken / $6 seafood
KIDS SIDES3 dishes
- SD Broccoli$4.00
- SD Carrots$4.00
- SD Mushrooms$4.00
EXTRAS27 dishes
- 1 MEATBALL$3.00
- 1/2 PINT DRESSING$4.00
- 4 Shrimp$11.00
- Add Chicken Breast$6.00
- ADULT SIZED MIXED VEG$8.00
- HOUSE BREAD LOAF$11.00
- MARINARA 1/2 Pint$4.00
- MARINARA PINT$8.00
- MARINARA QUART$16.00
- PESTO 1/2 Pint$16.00
- PESTO PINT$32.00
- PINT DRESSING$8.00
- QUART DRESSING$16.00
- Side Alfredo$1.00
- Side 4 Dinner Meatballs$12.00
- Side 2 Meatballs$6.00
- Side Marinara$1.00
- Side Pesto$1.00
- Side Pizza Sauce$0.50
- Soup Quart$15.00
- SOURDOUGH DOUGH BALLS$5.00
raw dough ball
- TRADITIONAL DOUGH BALLS$3.00
raw dough ball
- Salmon Filet 6 Oz$13.00
- Side House Dressing$0.75
- Avocado$2.00
- Side Of Beef Tips$10.00
- Crispy Chicken$7.00
Desserts8 dishes
- A La Mode$3.00
- Cookies$3.00
- Hummingbird Cake$12.00
- Lemon Tres Leches$10.00
- PB Pie$11.00
- Sticky Toffee$10.00
- Tiramisu$10.00
- Pears And Cheese$13.00