Skip to main content
BusinessesMap
Brewster's New Buffalo — Italian restaurants in New Buffalo

Brewster's New Buffalo

Italian restaurantsNew Buffalo, MI

4.6 out of 5 stars4.6(2,074 reviews)

Advertisements

Quick info

+1 269-469-3005
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo, United States 49117-1835

About Brewster's New Buffalo

Brewster's New Buffalo is an Italian restaurant at 11 W Merchant St in New Buffalo, Michigan, with a regional Italian menu of 223 dishes and a windowed atrium bar. The kitchen makes pasta, including a sausage and shrimp pasta, and pizzas, among them a sweet and spicy pie. For dessert, fresh-baked cookies are offered at the table or to take home. The bar pours cocktails and mocktails alongside the food menu. A private dining room gives groups a separate space to eat together. The restaurant usually has a wait at peak times.

Good to know

  • Reservations
    Accepts reservations
  • Parking
    Free parking lot · Free street parking
  • Accessibility
    Wheelchair: parking lot, restroom, seating
  • Good for kids
    Good for kids · High chairs · Kids' menu
  • Dietary
    Vegan options · Vegetarian options

Advertisements

Menu & Prices

223 dishes · mains $1–47
  • Acqua Panna Still Water$8.00
  • Arnold Palmer$4.00
  • Casa Mara Soda$8.00
  • Fever Tree$8.00
  • Flavored Pelligrino$5.00
  • Fresh Squeezed OJ$6.00
See full menu & prices →

Reviews

4.6/5
2,074 reviews

What reviewers say

Reviewers most often mention caesar salad, lemon basil chicken, complimentary dessert and cookies and patio seating.

5★
1,610
4★
277
3★
83
2★
29
1★
75

Customer Review Summary

Diners most often single out the lemon basil chicken and pasta, called fresh and not heavy. Close behind are the Caesar salad, sweet and spicy pizza, and sausage and shrimp pasta, with patio seating and well crafted cocktails praised. Servers are called attentive and fast. Some note tight parking and a wait at peak times. One reviewer recalls a hot peanut butter cookie, another a complimentary dessert.

Featured reviews

  • Carrie Meyer
    “We came here for the first time, celebrating a rehearsal dinner. The food was fresh and fantastic. The servers were very attentive, and kind to our large party! My husband and I did the 2 for $65 and truly enjoyed it. It was perfect, and served plenty of food for the both of us. We loved the lemon basil pasta, very unique and fresh!”
  • Christopher J. Smith
    “An Absolutely Amazing First Experience at Brewsters! Our first visit to Brewsters in New Buffalo, Michigan, was nothing short of exceptional! From the moment we checked in at the host stand to the moment we paid the bill, the entire experience was outstanding. Every interaction made us feel welcomed, appreciated, and genuinely taken care of. A special shout-out to our server, Brenna, who was absolutely phenomenal! She went above and beyond in every way, providing incredible service, paying attention to the little details, and making sure we had a wonderful experience from start to finish. It’s rare to come across someone who brings that level of genuine hospitality and care to their job, and Brenna truly made our visit special. We also want to give a big thank-you to the team for the complimentary dessert. It was such a thoughtful and appreciated gesture, and the perfect finishing touch to an already fantastic experience! As first-time guests, we couldn’t have asked for a better introduction to Brewsters. The hospitality, attention to detail, and overall experience made a lasting impression on us. We left feeling happy, appreciated, and already looking forward to coming back. Brewsters, you have something special here, and Brenna is a shining example of what exceptional hospitality looks like! Thank you for making our first visit so memorable. We’ll absolutely be back!”
  • Jill Thomas
    “Beautiful design, wonderful food, exceptional service! Breakfast with a friend. We both had coffee and the Hippie Mash with a side of eggs. Fresh and full of flavor! They also bring you a fresh baked mini muffin that melts in your mouth!”
  • Aaron Wells
    “Brewster’s has the kind of fun, lively atmosphere that reminds you why people still leave the house for a good meal. The food is great, the service is fast and friendly, and the whole place has an easygoing energy that makes you want to settle in and enjoy yourself. The specials are worth paying attention to, and the staff keeps things moving without making you feel rushed. Yes, parking can be a bit of a small-town endurance test. And yes, there can be a wait during peak times. But that’s usually the sign of a place doing something right. If you have the time, it’s worth it. Good food, good people, good atmosphere. Brewster’s earns the crowd. We’ve been dining here for years and will continue to do so.”
  • Melba Mira
    “What a fabulous experience - have been wanting to try for years and it did not disappoint. Staff seems treated well and genuinely happy. The outdoor seating is truly magical with just-right heat lamps. Best mocktail of my life with egg whites which took me back to great memories. We had the beef tips and lemon chicken - was surprised that lemon chicken came with pasta but must have read too quickly. Delicious GF option available for spinach artichoke dip did not disappoint. We called for a reservation about and hour and a half ahead of time. Had never seen a kitchen tip line on a bill before - not necessarily a negative, just new. Will be back 100% and can’t wait!”

Hours

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Highlights

“Handcrafted regional Italian food in cafe environs with homey decor & a windowed atrium bar.”

  • Fast service
  • Fireplace
  • Great beer selection
  • Great cocktails
  • Great coffee
  • Great dessert

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Accepts reservations
  • Outdoor seating
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
Show more amenities
  • Family-friendly
  • Vegan options
  • Bar onsite
  • Cozy
  • Onsite services
  • Beer
Offerings· 9
  • Alcohol
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Hard liquor
  • Private dining room
  • Small plates
  • Vegetarian options
  • Wine
Facilities· 1
  • Restroom
Crowd· 4
  • Groups
  • LGBTQ+ friendly
  • Tourists
  • Transgender safespace
Parking· 2
  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking
Dining options· 9
  • Breakfast
  • Brunch
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Catering
  • Counter service
  • Dessert
  • Seating
  • Table service
Popular for· 1
  • Solo dining
Accessibility· 2
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
Family-friendly· 3
  • Good for kids
  • High chairs
  • Kids' menu
Highlights· 8
  • Fast service
  • Fireplace
  • Great beer selection
  • Great cocktails
  • Great coffee
  • Great dessert
  • Great wine list
  • Serves local specialty
Atmosphere· 5
  • Casual
  • Quiet
  • Romantic
  • Trendy
  • Upscale
Planning· 2
  • Brunch reservations recommended
  • Dinner reservations recommended

Location

More to explore in New Buffalo

DirectionsCallMenu