
Cracked Conch Cafe
Advertisements
Quick info
About Cracked Conch Cafe
Cracked Conch Cafe is a restaurant in Marathon, Florida, at 4999 Overseas Hwy, with a menu of 188 dishes and plenty of sauce options. Seafood leads the kitchen, including Fried #1 Conch, and conch fritters and a conch basket are also on the menu. Breakfast is served too, with a blue crab and bacon eggs Benedict and Cubano coffee. For dessert, the kitchen fries its key lime pie and serves it with coconut ice cream. Inside, the decor follows a beach theme with old-time diner touches, and a small bar area has stools for drinks. Happy hour covers drinks and draft beer. Dogs are welcome.
Good to know
- ReservationsAccepts reservations
- ParkingFree parking lot · Free street parking · On-site parking
- AccessibilityWheelchair: entrance, parking lot, restroom, seating
- Good for kidsGood for kids · Has changing table(s) · High chairs
- DietaryOrganic dishes
Advertisements
Menu & Prices
188 dishes · mains $2–50- Two Eggs Any Style$8.00
- Fresh Mahi$16.99
- Country Fried Steak$15.99
- NY. Strip Steak$18.99
- Fried #1 Conch$19.95
- Roasted Pepper & Egg Hoagie$13.25
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention fried key lime pie, conch basket, fried green tomatoes and philly cheesesteak.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention fried key lime pie, conch basket, fried green tomatoes and philly cheesesteak.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers most often single out the fried key lime pie, served with coconut ice cream. The conch basket, onion rings, fried green tomatoes, Philly cheesesteak, and Cubano coffee also draw praise, along with friendly servers and a big menu. One dissenting reviewer sent back conch chowder that arrived without conch, then found the second bowl's conch pale and rubbery, and called the conch balls mushy filler.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers most often single out the fried key lime pie, served with coconut ice cream. The conch basket, onion rings, fried green tomatoes, Philly cheesesteak, and Cubano coffee also draw praise, along with friendly servers and a big menu. One dissenting reviewer sent back conch chowder that arrived without conch, then found the second bowl's conch pale and rubbery, and called the conch balls mushy filler.
Featured reviews
- Michael Logan
“Native Conch who grew up eating here since I was a kid growing up from Big Pine Key. Great casual local dining, friendly staff local seafood at a reasonable price. Easy parking indoor or outdoor seating. Consistent meeting place across from the Hurricane which is also a locals watering hole. Ice cold refreshing draft beer goes well with everything I have had on the menu. Check out their happy hr!”
- A K
“Omg the fried key lime pie is out of this world! Truly the best thing we ate in the Keys, and the coconut ice cream with it was the perfect touch. The conch basket and onion rings were also fantastic and a huge portion. Definitely check this gem out if you are in Marathon or passing through.”
- Rachelle Woodraska
“Stopped by Cracked Conch in Marathon and had such a great experience! We came during happy hour and enjoyed some drinks along with an order of fried green tomatoes to start—crispy, flavorful, and the perfect appetizer. Of course, we couldn’t leave without trying their famous key lime pie, and it absolutely lived up to the hype—refreshing, tangy, and the perfect sweet finish. The atmosphere was relaxed and welcoming, the service was friendly and attentive, and everything from the food to the drinks was spot on. Definitely a place we’ll be coming back to!”
- Jason Perlow
“Cracked Conch Cafe (Marathon) — This Is What We’re Accepting Now? If your conch chowder shows up without conch, and the solution is to add it afterward, that’s not a mistake — that’s how the kitchen is operating. First bowl: Sent back. No conch. None. Look at the photos — it’s vegetable soup. Second bowl: now there’s conch, but it’s clearly dropped in after the fact. Pale, rubbery, sitting on top like a garnish that showed up late. That’s not chowder. That’s a cover-up. And it doesn’t get better. Cut open the “conch balls”. Mushy filler with tiny bits of conch, greasy, fried hard to hold together. That’s not a conch fritter. Is that what a “ball” is supposed to be? Cracked conch? Uniform, tight, clearly from frozen. Ceviche? Overworked, rubbery, heavy oregano — more masking than seasoning. The place is doing steady business, so clearly there’s a loyal crowd here. Which brings us to the uncomfortable question: At what point do we stop giving a pass to places coasting on reputation and start expecting the food to match the name on the sign? Because this isn’t a small miss — this is the entire identity of the restaurant not being executed at a basic level. So I’ll ask it directly: If this is acceptable conch to you… what does good conch even look like?”
- Safi
“It was absolutely amazing here. The servers are so nice and even the new server was good! Food tasted good and they have many sauce options. Their menu is really big and plenty of variety of foods. It depends on what time of the day you come here, but we came at around 11am and left at around 12:30, and the whole time the whole restaurant stayed calm and clean. No weird smells or mystery crumbs on the seats, and they have different seating options, with seats inside, stools at the small bar area, and seats outdoors. The restaurant decor and beach themed coloring gives it a tropical fun vibe, while also feeling cozy. 5 stars, absolutely would come again!!”
Hours
- Monday
- Tuesday
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
Highlights
“Chill, long-running spot offering a menu of locally sourced seafood, plus outdoor seating.”
- Fast service
- Great beer selection
- Great cocktails
- Great coffee
- Great dessert
- Live music
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Accepts reservations
- Outdoor seating
- Dogs allowed
- Delivery
- Takeout
Show more amenities
- Dine-in
- Family-friendly
- Bar onsite
- Cozy
- Onsite services
- Beer
- Offerings· 12
- Alcohol
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Happy hour drinks
- Happy hour food
- Hard liquor
- Healthy options
- Organic dishes
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Wine
- Popular for· 1
- Solo dining
- Atmosphere· 2
- Casual
- Quiet
- Dining options· 8
- Breakfast
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Counter service
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
- Facilities· 1
- Restroom
- Crowd· 2
- Groups
- Tourists
- Family-friendly· 4
- Good for kids
- Has changing table(s)
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
- Highlights· 8
- Fast service
- Great beer selection
- Great cocktails
- Great coffee
- Great dessert
- Live music
- Serves local specialty
- Sports
- Accessibility· 3
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Parking· 3
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- On-site parking
- Pet-friendly· 1
- Dogs allowed outside
Location
Restaurants near Cracked Conch Cafe
- 4.1 mi
waterfront views, shrimp po' boy, tipsy siren cocktail
| Place | Rating | Distance | Mentioned in reviews |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cracked Conch CafeOutdoor seating · Wheelchair accessible · Good for kids | 4.32,375 | — | fried key lime pie, conch basket, fried green tomatoes |
| The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar | 4.48,944 | 4.1 mi | waterfront views, shrimp po' boy, tipsy siren cocktail |
The 1 nearest restaurants by distance. Ratings, hours and review terms come from public business profiles.
More to explore in Marathon
Places in Marathon
See all places in Marathon