Skip to main content
BusinessesMap
The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar — Restaurants in Marathon

The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar

RestaurantsMarathon, FL

4.4 out of 5 stars4.4(8,944 reviews)

Advertisements

Quick info

+1 305-743-4191
12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050, United States

Follow

About The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar

The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar is a waterside restaurant and tiki bar at 12648 Overseas Hwy in Marathon, FL, with views over the water. The menu runs to 144 items, with seafood at the center. The shrimp po' boy sits beside a French Dip sandwich with provolone, so the list reaches past fish. The bar side of the operation pours the Tipsy Siren cocktail. Beer is listed in two sizes, 12oz and 24oz, across labels like Michelob Ultra, Yuengling Lager and Dos Equis Amber.

Advertisements

Menu & Prices

144 dishes · mains $2–100
  • MICHELOB ULTRA 12oz$4.25
  • MICHELOB ULTRA 24oz$8.00
  • YUENGLING LAGER 12oz$4.50
  • YUENGLING LAGER 24oz$8.00
  • DOS EQUIS AMBER 12oz$5.00
  • DOS EQUIS AMBER 24oz$9.00
See full menu & prices →

Reviews

4.4/5
8,944 reviews

What reviewers say

Reviewers most often mention waterfront views, shrimp po' boy, tipsy siren cocktail and french dip sandwich.

5★
5,802
4★
1,729
3★
686
2★
309
1★
418

Customer Review Summary

Reviewers most often single out the waterfront seating, where one watched marine wildlife during lunch. Orders named include a shrimp po' boy with a Tipsy Siren and a French Dip with provolone, with tender beef full of flavor. One repeat visitor calls the food delicious and fresh, though another found it decent but not memorable. One reviewer also noticed fresh flowers in the ladies' room.

Featured reviews

  • Kahro “Kahro7” N
    “🌴 Quintessential Florida Keys vibes, served waterfront! 🐠🌴 The Island Fish Co. in Marathon is exactly what you picture when you imagine a classic Florida Keys tiki bar & restaurant — laid-back, colorful, breezy, and right on the water. I went with the shrimp po’ boy and paired it with a Tipsy Siren because apparently waterfront lunch calls for a vacation cocktail. 🍹🦐 The best part? That gorgeous waterfront setting. I enjoyed watching marine wildlife while eating lunch 🦈 And I have to give a special shoutout to the ladies’ room. 🌸 Real, fresh flowers! Such a small detail, but it made me smile. I’ve actually seen this before at a gas station in Vermont — so whoever is responsible for fresh flowers in unexpected places, I see you! 💐 If you’re looking for an affordable waterfront lunch with quintessential Keys atmosphere, put The Island Fish Co. on your Marathon list. 🌴 Waterfront views 🦐 Shrimp po’ boy 🍹 Tipsy Siren 🌸 Fresh flowers 🐠 Total Florida Keys energy Come for the views, stay for the Keys vibes.”
  • Melissa
    “We had a wonderful experience at Island Fish Co. in Marathon! We are repeat visitors and enjoy the food here each time we come. The food is always delicious and fresh, the service is excellent, and the atmosphere is exactly what you want …”
  • Adam Soper
    “We stopped at Island Fish Co. in Marathon for lunch and had a really lovely experience. I ordered the French Dip sandwich with provolone cheese, which was really good. The beef was tender, full of flavour and the chips were good too. The restaurant has a lovely relaxed atmosphere, and sitting overlooking the water was definitely a highlight. Service was lovely from start to finish, with absolutely no complaints. We also thought it was good value for money, especially considering the location. Overall, a really enjoyable lunch with good food, lovely service and a beautiful view. We’d happily return!”
  • Raymond Bewry
    “My friends and I recently visited this seafood restaurant and had a thoroughly enjoyable dining experience. We all chose different dishes from the menu, and each of us was impressed by the quality, presentation, and preparation of our …”
  • Tarek Salah El Din
    “This waterfront restaurant has one of the best views in the area. Sitting outside while enjoying the beautiful scenery made for a relaxing experience, and the family-friendly atmosphere was a big plus. The staff was welcoming, and it's a nice spot to spend time with loved ones. The food, however, didn't quite live up to the setting. While it was decent, it wasn't especially memorable or as flavorful as we had hoped. Overall, I'd still recommend visiting for the amazing waterfront views and pleasant family atmosphere, but I'd go with modest expectations for the food.”

Hours

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Good to know

“Waterside tiki bar/eatery pairing seafood classics such as coconut shrimp with frozen drinks.”

  • Accessibility
    Has wheelchair-accessible car park · Has wheelchair-accessible entrance · Has wheelchair-accessible seating

Amenities

  • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Show more amenities
Accessibility· 3
  • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet

Location

DirectionsCallMenu