Skip to main content
BusinessesMap
Dominick's Italian-American Deli — Delis in New Hyde Park

Dominick's Italian-American Deli

DelisNew Hyde Park, NY

4.6 out of 5 stars4.6(1,071 reviews)

Advertisements

Quick info

+1 516-746-2116
401 Herricks Rd, New Hyde Park, United States 11040

About Dominick's Italian-American Deli

Dominick's Italian-American Deli is an Italian-style deli at 401 Herricks Rd in New Hyde Park, NY, built around a deli counter and a selection of prepared foods. Chicken fingers star in the Kevincito Special, which pairs them with fresh mozzarella and broccoli rabe. Chicken cutlet sandwiches are on the menu, and so is the Southwest, which comes with chipotle mayo. Fried chicken cutlets are sold to go. Soups and salads sit alongside the hot and cold sandwiches. Orders go through the counter, not a sit-down room, and a line and a wait are common inside. Sandwiches can be ordered in bulk for parties and events, and they can be cut in thirds.

Advertisements

Reviews

4.6/5
1,071 reviews

What reviewers say

Reviewers most often mention chicken fingers, italian-style sandwiches, chicken cutlet sandwiches and southwest sandwich.

5★
848
4★
137
3★
26
2★
22
1★
38

Customer Review Summary

Reviewers most often single out the chicken fingers, with the Southwest sandwich (chipotle mayo), the Broadway, and chicken cutlet sandwiches close behind. Several describe big sandwich portions and a busy, chaotic counter. One says portions have shrunk since past years, and another describes a Sunday line out the door, a slow wait, and people cutting in line. One adds cole slaw was excellent.

Featured reviews

  • John Grasso
    “A true Long Island deli! Dominick's is the kind of old-school Italian deli that gets the job done. The staff works hard, keeps things moving, and you can tell they're putting in the effort. It's not really a sit down and eat kind of place, but that's not what you're coming here for. The food gets the job done, and it's a solid local spot when you're looking for a good Italian deli. Always nice to support a true Long Island business!”
  • PJ Fly
    “Came in today on a Sunday. I mean you have 3 workers chit chatting with a line that goes out the door for a mid 3/10 sandwich place isn't worth it. Waited 45 minutes for a basic sandwich and for the owner having his buddies cut the line there is no organization. Plenty of other places to go and not wait a near hour for a poorly made sandwich. Youlll thank me to turn around and head iiout.”
  • Elizabeth S. Hunt
    “My experience was wonderful. The food and service was great! Dont forget to sign up for rewards, because you will go back there! I was welcomed with smiles. Marco was kind when he knew it was my first visit! The conversations w/ Danielle, Rosy, and Dom Jr. we're enjoyable (I'm a talker🤭).”
  • K P
    “Dominick’s never failed me. Their sandwiches and chicken fingers are so delicious. The staff is super cool. The restaurant is very clean. There’s plenty of parking. The prices are very reasonable. I got the Manhattan.”
  • Josephine Chu
    “Very chaotic inside - always a good sign of business. We ordered a dozen sandwiches for church and had them cut in thirds to try. The Southwest was my favorite with a kick of chipotle mayo, but many others enjoyed the Broadway. If this is your first time and you only have stomach space for one sandwich - try one of their chicken cutlet sandwiches first before exploring their roast beefs. They’re known for their chicken fingers, but portion sizes seem to have decreased compared to photos in past years.”

Hours

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Good to know

“Longtime eatery serving Italian & American hot & cold sandwiches, along with soups & salads.”

  • Parking
    Free parking lot · Free street parking
  • Accessibility
    Wheelchair: entrance, parking lot

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • In-store pickup
  • Onsite services
  • Restroom
Show more amenities
  • Free parking lot
  • Quick visit
Service options· 1
  • In-store shopping
Accessibility· 1
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Parking· 1
  • Free street parking

Location

Delis near Dominick's Italian-American Deli

Dominick's Italian-American Deli
4.61,071
  • 3.5 mi

    bacon egg and cheese, hungry man hero, homemade soup

  • 5.6 mi away

    bacon egg and cheese, turkey sandwich, chicken parmesan hero

The 2 nearest delis by distance. Ratings, hours and review terms come from public business profiles.

DirectionsCallTop