
Applegate Farm
Advertisements
Quick info
About Applegate Farm
Applegate Farm is an ice cream shop in Montclair, NJ, at 616 Grove St, and the flagship stand for ice cream made on a farm that dates to the 1840s. The ice cream is homemade, and the menu runs to 38 items across cones, cups, sundaes, milk shakes and Italian ice. "The Farm" Sundae and the Applegate Freeze sit alongside flavors like Apple Cider Donut. Scoops are served in cow-print cups, and toppings and fudge are available for building a sundae. The stand has several serving areas and a few spots to sit and eat. A parking lot is on site, and there are no restrooms.
Good to know
- ParkingFree parking lot · On-site parking
- AccessibilityWheelchair: entrance, parking lot
- Good for kidsGood for kids
Advertisements
Menu & Prices
38 dishes · mains $5–86- Medium Cone/Cup$9.28
- Large Sundae$11.87
- Medium Milk Shake$10.34
- Applegate Freeze$8.22
- Small Italian Ice$5.46
- "The Farm" Sundae$48.26
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention graham central station ice cream, rum raisin, cherry vanilla and apple cider donut ice cream.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention graham central station ice cream, rum raisin, cherry vanilla and apple cider donut ice cream.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers praise the homemade ice cream, naming Graham Central Station, Rum Raisin, and pistachio loaded with whole pistachios, with cherry vanilla, strawberry, and apple cider donut also mentioned. Long lines are the recurring complaint, tied to weekend evenings and TikTok attention, and one reviewer found service slow and understaffed. One says the Choc Chip Cookie Dough needs a reboot. Scoops arrive in cow-print cups.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers praise the homemade ice cream, naming Graham Central Station, Rum Raisin, and pistachio loaded with whole pistachios, with cherry vanilla, strawberry, and apple cider donut also mentioned. Long lines are the recurring complaint, tied to weekend evenings and TikTok attention, and one reviewer found service slow and understaffed. One says the Choc Chip Cookie Dough needs a reboot. Scoops arrive in cow-print cups.
Featured reviews
- Leonardo Mulero
“This place is fantastic. I've been coming here forever. I sampled and enjoyed a bunch of flavors, sundaes and toppings. Everything is above average except for the Choc Chip Cookie Dough. It needs a massive reboot and it should be taken off the menu until its greatly improved. Anyways, thanks for great service and wonderful memories. I'll be back tomorrow to redeem my recent experience. Ciao for now.”
- Kyrsten Hernandez
“Ice cream was really good, there are long lines due to them blowing up on Tik tok which I don’t mind, they don’t have bathrooms if you need to use one. I ordered the apple cider donut ice cream and it was really good.”
- Harikrishna Chavda
“The ice cream is amazing, but waiting over an hour just to get one scoop of ice-cream is ridiculous. The queues are far too long, and the service is painfully slow. They clearly need more staff. The employees we encountered seemed lazy and completely unhelpful.”
- TK [Caffeine & Chaos]
“Applegates Farm Ice Cream is an awesome spot with incredible, great-tasting homemade ice cream, but be prepared for a wait if you visit on a weekend evening. When heading there on a Saturday night, the line can easily stretch to around 45 minutes. However, the rich, delicious scoops served in their classic cow-print cups make the wait completely worthwhile.”
- Mike Zito
“In operation since 1848, they have a big selection of homemade ice cream. I had the pistachio which was delicious and loaded with whole pistachios. I have never been disappointed here. There is plenty of parking. They have several serving areas but lines can be long and parking difficult. But it is worth the wait.”
Hours
- Monday
- Tuesday
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
Highlights
“This is the flagship stand for ice cream made on a farm dating from the 1840s.”
- Popular for solo dining
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
- Good for kids
- Cozy
Show more amenities
- Onsite services
- Solo dining
- Trending
- Trendy
- Free parking lot
- Quick visit
- Dining options· 1
- Table service
- Accessibility· 1
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Atmosphere· 1
- Casual
- Parking· 1
- On-site parking
- Crowd· 1
- Groups