Mystic Brows
Quick info
About Mystic Brows
Mystic Brows is an eyebrow bar on S Westnedge Ave in Portage, located next to Kohl's and TJ Maxx in the Southland Mall area, sharing an entrance with Roxy's Tailoring. The bar previously operated inside the mall before moving to this storefront. Threading is the core service, carried out by a single practitioner rather than a rotating staff. Visits are walk-in, with no appointment required. The bar opens Monday through Saturday and stays closed on Sundays.
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention eyebrow threading, $8 threading promotion, uneven or thinned brows and new location by tj maxx.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention eyebrow threading, $8 threading promotion, uneven or thinned brows and new location by tj maxx.
Customer Review Summary
Eyebrow threading is the clear draw here, with many reviewers praising the shape and lasting results and noting it holds up better and irritates skin less than waxing. Several mention following the shop through its move from the mall to the Westnedge location next to Kohl's and TJ Maxx, calling the service quick and professional and saying they return specifically because they trust no one else with their brows. That said, the experience is inconsistent: complaints describe brows thinned into a rounded line instead of the requested arch, one side left noticeably skinnier than the other, and wax residue left on the skin afterward. Another reviewer felt the result wasn't thorough enough and needed touch-up plucking at home despite paying full price for the service. A newer transplant from NY notes trying a nearby threading spot first and finding the brows taken "way too thin" there before switching to this shop instead.
Customer Review Summary
Eyebrow threading is the clear draw here, with many reviewers praising the shape and lasting results and noting it holds up better and irritates skin less than waxing. Several mention following the shop through its move from the mall to the Westnedge location next to Kohl's and TJ Maxx, calling the service quick and professional and saying they return specifically because they trust no one else with their brows. That said, the experience is inconsistent: complaints describe brows thinned into a rounded line instead of the requested arch, one side left noticeably skinnier than the other, and wax residue left on the skin afterward. Another reviewer felt the result wasn't thorough enough and needed touch-up plucking at home despite paying full price for the service. A newer transplant from NY notes trying a nearby threading spot first and finding the brows taken "way too thin" there before switching to this shop instead.
Featured reviews
- Danielle Mellado
“This is the worst eyebrow threading I’ve ever had!! The only reason I tipped was because she provided a service. I have 2 different skinny eyebrows. Was told I had to grow 1 side in. Well duh, now I do!”
- Judy Robinson
“She took off way too much on one brow and thinned out the other one she left wax all on my brows horrible experience”
- Joons Moons
“before and after! I'm so happy with the results! They do a wonderful job here”
- denise Knox
“Always great experience when i get my brows done”
- chloe
“The shop appears clean and well-maintained, and the woman who does the threading is decent. However, I was a bit disappointed to pay $15 and still need to touch up my eyebrows at home with additional plucking. I expected a more thorough result for the price.”
Hours
- Monday
- Tuesday
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
- Closed
Good to know
- ReservationsWalk-in only
- AccessibilityHas wheelchair-accessible car park · Has wheelchair-accessible entrance · Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Amenities
- Has wheelchair-accessible car park
- On-site services available
- Has toilet
Show more amenities
- Accessibility· 2
- Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Location
Browse more
Explore more of Portage.