
DiMaggio's Pizza and Burgers
Advertisements
Quick info
About DiMaggio's Pizza and Burgers
DiMaggio's Pizza and Burgers is a pizza restaurant in Coloma, Michigan, at 6410 M-63, and the family has owned it since 1957. The menu lists 97 dishes, with pizza and burgers both served and a thick crust option for the pizzas. One pie pairs sausage and mushroom with fennel. The salad section includes the Antipasto and the Anchovie Plate, plus chef salads in small and large sizes. A bar area sits inside the restaurant, and food comes out on paper plates. Payment is cash only and credit cards are not accepted, so an ATM is available on site.
Good to know
- ParkingFree parking lot · Free street parking
- AccessibilityWheelchair: parking lot, seating
- Good for kidsHigh chairs · Kids' menu
Advertisements
Menu & Prices
97 dishes- Tossed Dinner Salad
- Large Dinner Salad
- Small Chef Salad
- Large Chef Salad
- Anchovie Plate
- Antipasto
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention pizza, burgers, thick crust pizza and sausage mushroom pizza.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention pizza, burgers, thick crust pizza and sausage mushroom pizza.
Customer Review Summary
Pizza anchors the praise, especially the thick crust, described as fluffy and crunchy, and a sausage mushroom pie heavy on fennel. Burgers are called above average. Complaints are real, though: one found the crust bland with ham slices sliding off, another got a watery, burned veggie pizza, and one felt overcharged for toppings. Service earns praise too, with one server bringing extra sauce unasked.
Customer Review Summary
Pizza anchors the praise, especially the thick crust, described as fluffy and crunchy, and a sausage mushroom pie heavy on fennel. Burgers are called above average. Complaints are real, though: one found the crust bland with ham slices sliding off, another got a watery, burned veggie pizza, and one felt overcharged for toppings. Service earns praise too, with one server bringing extra sauce unasked.
Featured reviews
- Tanya S
“The service was amazing! Our server made us feel like we were regulars and this was our first time here. She was helpful and so friendly. The pizza we ordered was pretty good but the extra sauce she brought us (without us even asking)made it even better! We appreciated the hospitality and left with full bellies! Our only complaint is that they didn’t take credit cards but not the end of the world.”
- Laura D
“I’ll say the pro first: I think they use real mozzarella. The cheese was chees’n! And the pepperonis were perfectly crispy! I don’t like to be a downer, but this pizza was not what we expected. It also was far more expensive than we anticipated. We were driving through the area and so I called in a pickup order. I got what normally would be considered a 2-topping pizza, but was charged for 4 toppings. (I asked for 1/2 & 1/2). I was surprised at the $26 price. The crust was homemade and good texture mostly, but bland. The sausage left much to be desired. The way they cut their ham (in large slices) made it so the toppings on that side of the pizza fell right off. It’s truly a knife and fork pizza. I love a local shop. So if you go, ask questions about pricing if that matters to you & be prepared with salt, fork & knife.”
- Melody Kelly
“What a gem! Any establishment thriving in the same location for seventy years must be doing something right. The atmosphere is quaint and homey. There's an inviting bar populated by friendly locals. Nancy, who has been here twenty-eight of their seventy years, will take expert care of you. DiMaggio's is worth going out of your way.”
- zeus winston
“Sausage mushroom pizza is great lots of fennel got mine well done and took 20 min.”
- Jon Homrich
“This place is awesome, and amazing how a vehicle break down can lead you to discover the best pizza I have had. I was out here fixing a customers central vacuum and my van decided to break down outside of their parking lot. The owner was very kind and understanding the rest of the staff are also awesome and friendly and go above and beyond. I will be making a trip here again with my wife. PS order the thick crust, it’s the right amount of fluffy and crunchy.”
Hours
- Monday
- Closed
- Tuesday
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
Highlights
- Great cocktails
- Serves local specialty
- Sports
- Popular for solo dining
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Dine-in
- Kids' menu
- Cozy
- Onsite services
- Late-night food
Show more amenities
- Dessert
- Great cocktails
- Serves local specialty
- Sports
- Solo dining
- Free parking lot
- Dining options· 2
- Counter service
- Seating
- Accessibility· 1
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Crowd· 2
- Groups
- Tourists
- Parking· 1
- Free street parking
- Offerings· 1
- Quick bite
- Atmosphere· 1
- Casual
- Family-friendly· 1
- High chairs