Skip to main content
BusinessesMap
Brotherhood of Thieves — American restaurants in Nantucket

Brotherhood of Thieves

American restaurantsNantucket, MA

4.5 out of 5 stars4.5(1,095 reviews)

Advertisements

Quick info

+1 774-325-5812
23 Broad St, Nantucket, United States 02554

About Brotherhood of Thieves

Brotherhood of Thieves is an American restaurant at 23 Broad St in Nantucket, with an interior themed to the 1800s, a fireplace, and live music. The menu runs to 63 dishes, including the Boom Boom Shrimp, spicy rigatoni, and a Veggie Burger. Bar seating comes with local selections from Cisco Brewery. Dogs are welcome, so guests can bring their pets along. When the restaurant is busy, a wait for a table is common. An upstairs event room hosts large group lunches.

Good to know

  • Reservations
    Accepts reservations
  • Parking
    Free street parking
  • Accessibility
    Wheelchair: entrance, restroom, seating
  • Good for kids
    Good for kids · High chairs · Kids' menu
  • Dietary
    Vegetarian options

Advertisements

Menu & Prices

63 dishes · mains $10–55
  • Cisco Burger$27.60
  • Reverend Foster Burger$25.30
  • Brotherhood Burger$25.30
  • Veggie Burger$23.00
  • BBQ Burger$27.60
  • Side Sweet Potato$9.20
See full menu & prices →

Reviews

4.5/5
1,095 reviews

What reviewers say

Reviewers most often mention spicy rigatoni, caesar salad, boom boom shrimp and sole piccata.

5★
750
4★
214
3★
62
2★
25
1★
44

Customer Review Summary

Diners most often praise the spicy rigatoni, with the caesar salad close behind and the veggie burger, Boom Boom Shrimp, and crème brûlée also singled out. Portions are called generous. On the downside, one Latin salmon arrived cold and another table waited on two delayed orders. Bachelorette groups describe a server offering a group photo and flowers placed on the table.

Featured reviews

  • Laura Eng
    “Sat in the outdoor patio area which was perfect for lunch. The service was also great; our waitress was really nice and very attentive throughout. Both the caesar salad and the lobster fettuccine were delicious!”
  • Afia Ahmed
    “When we arrived, pleasantly greeted by the hostess outside and informed of an hour wait. Luckily a table opened up sooner and we were seated 30 minutes later. Interior is quirky but fitting of the theme (1800’s). Busy for a Tuesday night so it did take 20-25 minutes for food to be served but it was well worth the wait. Watermelon lemonade was made in house and worth the calories. We skipped the apps because it was leg day and we needed protein but they all looked delectable We ordered steak frites and vodka pasta with crusted chicken. Steak was cooked to perfect with a perfect chimichuri. Pasta was al dente and sauce was flavorful. The chicken could have used a pinch of garlic salt in my opinion. Portions were generous leaving no room for dessert. Our server was attentive and patient. Also loved the in house merchandise! Got my husband a Nantucket souvenir hat. Will definitely come back”
  • Amy Anderson
    “The restaurant was very accommodating as our ferry arrived late and parking was a challenge. Our server Melissa was awesome! My husband has a shell fish allergy and she was able to offer him suggestions which was very helpful. She recommended me the Sole Piccata. The presentation and flavors were delightful. We ordered a variety of meals. Nashville Hot sandwich, Salmon Noodle Bowl, Spicy Rigatoni, Fish and Chips, Sole Piccata and children’s pasta with butter. All were delicious!!”
  • Alia Mohsen
    “Sharing SO much gratitude for the The Brotherhood of Thieves team for making our bachelorette dinner so special! They were able to accommodate our group of 8 right after a very busy Labor Day weekend, and even though I’m sure the entire team was exhausted, you would never have known it. Our waiter was incredibly kind and attentive, and even offered to take a photo of our group when he heard we were celebrating my bachelorette party. The manager (I believe his name was Jack — eek, I hope I have that right!) stopped by not once, but twice, just to make sure we were having a good time. We absolutely were! They even put flowers on the table to make the occasion feel extra special. Every little touch was so thoughtful, and the food was fantastic. There really is something for everyone on the menu, and we had fun with the live music too. It made for such a fun, memorable night. Thank you to the entire Brotherhood team for taking such great care of us and helping make my bachelorette weekend even more special. We had the best time and will happily recommend you to anyone visiting Nantucket!”
  • Rene Stuart
    “Our first night in Nantucket, we decided to have dinner at Brotherhood of Thieves, and it turned out to be such a lovely start to our stay. We were lucky to get a table because this place is clearly very popular—it was busy the entire time we were there. We sat outside in the covered patio area, which was perfect for a beautiful evening. Our server, Brook, was exceptionally lovely, as was Victoria, who was training with her. Brook was warm, friendly and attentive throughout our dinner, and being a Nantucket local, she also gave us some great recommendations for things to see and do while we're here. My husband ordered the veggie burger with salad and fries, which he really enjoyed. The portions here are incredibly generous—the side salad was easily big enough to share! We appreciated Brook mentioning that the regular salads are quite large before we ordered. I chose the Latin salmon. The salmon itself was well cooked and I enjoyed the flavours of the dish, but unfortunately it arrived cold, which was disappointing. Aside from that, I enjoyed my meal. Of course, we couldn't leave without dessert! I had the crème brûlée, which was delicious—smooth, creamy and exactly what I was hoping for. My husband chose the strawberry shortcake, which was another great choice. Overall, we had a wonderful evening. Great atmosphere, generous portions and, most importantly, genuinely lovely service. Brook and Victoria made our first evening in Nantucket that much more enjoyable. Highly recommend Brotherhood of Thieves, and we'd happily return!”

Hours

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Highlights

“Family-friendly pick featuring hearty eats, craft beers, a patio & a cozy fireplace.”

  • Fast service
  • Fireplace
  • Great beer selection
  • Great cocktails
  • Great dessert
  • Great wine list

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Free street parking
  • Accepts reservations
  • Outdoor seating
  • Dogs allowed outside
  • No-contact delivery
Show more amenities
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Good for kids
  • Vegetarian options
  • Alcohol
  • Cozy
Offerings· 11
  • Beer
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Happy hour drinks
  • Hard liquor
  • Healthy options
  • Late-night food
  • Quick bite
  • Small plates
  • Wine
Popular for· 1
  • Solo dining
Facilities· 1
  • Restroom
Service options· 2
  • Curbside pickup
  • Delivery
Highlights· 8
  • Fast service
  • Fireplace
  • Great beer selection
  • Great cocktails
  • Great dessert
  • Great wine list
  • Live music
  • Serves local specialty
Accessibility· 2
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
Planning· 1
  • Dinner reservations recommended
Dining options· 5
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Dessert
  • Seating
  • Table service
Atmosphere· 3
  • Casual
  • Historic
  • Trendy
Crowd· 2
  • Groups
  • Tourists
Family-friendly· 2
  • High chairs
  • Kids' menu

Location

DirectionsCallMenu