Skip to main content
BusinessesMap
Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza — Pizza restaurants in Tampa

Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza

Pizza restaurantsTampa, FL

4.6 out of 5 stars4.6(8,062 reviews)

Advertisements

Quick info

+1 813-229-8500
203 E Twiggs St, Tampa, FL 33602, United States

Follow

About Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza

Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza is a pizza restaurant in Tampa at 203 E Twiggs St, just across the street from the Riverwalk. The kitchen turns out thin-crust New York-style pizza made with New York water, sold as a whole pie or as a giant slice. The default pie is 20 inches, and a display at the counter shows which slices are available, including cheese, supreme and Buffalo chicken, plus specialty slices. The GIANT Pepperoni Slice W/Ranch Dip comes with a ranch dip on the side. The 76-dish menu also goes beyond pizza, with cheese fries and Mozzarella Cheese Stix. Service is counter-style: you order at the register, then take a seat until the food is ready.

Advertisements

Menu & Prices

76 dishes · mains $7–59
  • FRIES$6.99
  • CHEESE FRIES$7.99
  • MOZZARELLA CHEESE STIX$8.99
  • 3-2 Ounce Meatballs W/Tomato Sauce And Basil$8.99
  • GIANT Cheese Slice W/Ranch Dip$7.99
  • GIANT Pepperoni Slice W/Ranch Dip$8.99
See full menu & prices →

Reviews

4.6/5
8,062 reviews

What reviewers say

Reviewers most often mention huge pizza slices, ny style pizza, supreme slice and buffalo chicken slice.

5★
6,192
4★
1,175
3★
360
2★
129
1★
206

Customer Review Summary

Reviewers point to the oversized New York style slices as the main draw, with a supreme slice and Buffalo chicken slices singled out, plus mozzarella sticks. One visitor from New York found the flavor familiar. Complaints are split. One found the cheese slice's sauce too sweet. Another got a half pepperoni that arrived as plain cheese and cold, and was offered only a credit.

Featured reviews

  • Shandy Rivera
    “I ordered half pepperoni, half meat lover. Got home and the half pepperoni was only cheese. In addition the pizza was cold. I had to heat it. When I called to notify them, they only offered to give a $2 credit for the missing pepperoni. She said there was nothing else they could do and also told me she couldn't give me the manager's name. When I told her I was going to write a bad review. She said yeah okay.”
  • Rick
    “After spending a few hours at this year's Tampa Bay Comic Convention, and walking the Riverwalk, we built up a bit of an appetite. Eddie and Sam's wasn't completely foreign to me, as I have heard about their pizza for quite a few years. As a classic pizza parlor, you place your order at the counter, then grab a seat until your food is ready. After checking the display to see what pizza choices were available, I opted for a slice of cheese and a slice of supreme, along with a fountain soda. My brother chose two slices with Buffalo chicken and a bottled soda. Both orders were around the $12-$15 range, which I found reasonable. Arriving at what I thought would be a bit of an off-hour (3PM on a Saturday), the place was busy, but we easily found available seating. Our food was served nice and hot, with just the right amount of scorch on the bottom. Toppings were distributed very liberally across each slice. I appreciated the size of the slices, which were quite large compared to some of the other guys. I believe Eddie and Sam's default is a 20" pie versus what I think is a more typical 16" or 18" pie. Each slice folded with just the right amount of crunch, had just the right amount of grease drip off, and held up even under the weight of substantial toppings. While I enjoyed the pizza immensely, the cheese slice was lacking a little something for me. I think maybe the sauce was a bit too sweet for my tastes, but that is fine - to each his own. The supreme slice, on the other hand, was fantastic, with a wonderfully balanced variety of veggies and meats. My brother declared his Buffalo chicken slices to be very good as well. He did not find that the Buffalo sauce overpowering the taste of the pizza at all. As I mentioned earlier, my brother opted to get a bottle of soda rather than the fountain soda. Ultimately, he wound up getting a second bottle, and what he noticed was that he grabbed a 16-ounce bottle in one refrigerator, and a 20-ounce bottle in the other. This is something for others to keep an eye out for if getting a bottled drink. I don't know if it was because I had been craving a good slice of pizza for several weeks leading up to this visit or not, but Eddie and Sam's really REALLY hit the spot.”
  • Kelly Jackson
    “THE BEST NY Style pizza in Tampa!! Great selections, HUGE pizza slices and also great menu additions (mozzarella sticks, etc.). We stop here almost every time we venture into the city. It's in an amazing location - just across the street from the Riverwalk. I absolutely recommend this place for your pizza cravings!”
  • Chris
    “We came from Wesley Chapel because of the glowing reviews, and I honestly can't understand them. We're pizza people. Our favorites include Pizza Box, Santoro's, The NONA Slice …”
  • Evan Gareau
    “Great experience! Myself, being from NY, could appreciate the flavor of their pizza and the style of this pizzeria! A more familiar flavor compared with other pizzas from down here. They also had a lot more specialty slices available @ the …”

Hours

Monday
Closed
Tuesday
Closed
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Good to know

“Thin-crust pizza by the pie or slice made with New York water at a casual, counter-serve spot.”

  • Accessibility
    Has wheelchair-accessible entrance · Has wheelchair-accessible seating · Has wheelchair-accessible toilet

Amenities

  • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Show more amenities
Accessibility· 2
  • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet

Location

More to explore in Tampa

Armature Works, Tampa

5 places

Restaurants in Tampa

Photo: Armature Works · 4.7 · 16,200 Google reviews

See all 5 restaurants in Tampa
DirectionsCallMenu