
Sally's Ice Cream
Advertisements
Quick info
About Sally's Ice Cream
Sally's Ice Cream is an ice cream shop in Flagler Beach, FL, at 401 N Ocean Shore Blvd, directly across from the beach. The flavors are made in house and the lineup rotates, with 42 items on the menu. Scoop options include Almond Amaretto and Black Cherry Salted Caramel, and the Banana Split is on the list too. Soft serve, milkshakes and hot fudge sundaes round out the menu, and dairy-free vegan options are available. A kids cone is offered for younger customers. Orders are placed at service windows, and the line can build up quickly. Dogs are welcome.
Good to know
- ParkingFree parking lot · Free street parking
- AccessibilityWheelchair: entrance, parking lot, seating, restroom
- Good for kidsGood for kids · Family-friendly
Advertisements
Menu & Prices
42 dishes- Frozen Yogurt #1
- Frozen Yogurt #2
- Almond Amaretto
- Black Cherry Salted Caramel
- Butter Pecan
- Banana Split
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention milkshakes, hot fudge sundae, caramel brownie explosion and dairy free vegan options.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention milkshakes, hot fudge sundae, caramel brownie explosion and dairy free vegan options.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers most often praise the house-made ice cream, calling it delicious, smooth, and creamy, with a large flavor selection. Close behind are the hot fudge sundae, milkshakes, and dairy free vegan options. A few complaints surface: ice cream served with a milkshake consistency, inconsistent portions, and a family in line before closing who watched the service window slide shut.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers most often praise the house-made ice cream, calling it delicious, smooth, and creamy, with a large flavor selection. Close behind are the hot fudge sundae, milkshakes, and dairy free vegan options. A few complaints surface: ice cream served with a milkshake consistency, inconsistent portions, and a family in line before closing who watched the service window slide shut.
Featured reviews
- Stephen Cohen
“We stopped by Sally's Ice Cream after dinner because it was highly recommended by family. We arrived at 8:58 PM, two minutes before the posted 9:00 PM closing time. There was one customer ahead of us placing an order, so we waited our turn with our 7-year-old. As soon as the customer in front of us finished ordering, the employee slid the service window shut, revealing the "Closed" sign. She didn't say a single word to us or acknowledge that we had been standing there waiting before closing time. When another employee opened the second window to hand out an order, we asked if they had really just closed while we were already waiting in line. The response was simply, "Yes," followed by an explanation that honestly didn't make sense given that we had arrived before closing. Businesses certainly have the right to close at their posted time, but customers who are already in line before closing should, at the very least, be treated with basic courtesy. A simple, "I'm sorry, we're no longer able to take additional orders," would have gone a long way. Instead, the interaction felt dismissive and left a very disappointed 7-year-old wondering why he couldn't get the ice cream he had been looking forward to all evening. Unfortunately, that experience was enough for us. There are plenty of places that serve great ice cream and make customers feel welcome. We won't be returning to Sally's.”
- DMarx
“Sweetest little treat on the beach! This place was run by some real fun kids!! Definitely the type to investigate when they hear a spooky sound in the night. 40 years ago they would be riding around in a large van solving mysteries up and down the coast with some assistance from a large dog of some sorts. Their vehicle would say something like “Sally’s superstitious ship” and they would proverbially unmask creatures and monsters preventing them from scaring off tourists. Man what a unique idea. I think I’m on to something here. I’m gonna write a screenplay based on this idea alone and put “dedicated to the Caramel Brownie Explosion” in a tasteful cursive writing during the opening credits- as a subtle nod to this amazing hole in the wall - I would refer to as Fernandinho beach’s best kept secret”
- Sheena
“Reasonable prices and delicious ice cream, soft serve, milkshakes and my favorite... Hot fudge sundae! The line builds up rather quickly but the team stays on top of it so the service is pretty fast. There are 4 picnic tables to sit at or you can take your ice cream and walk across to the beach .. I love Sally's Ice Cream, and have been a customer for several years! Yummy yum! 😊”
- Paul Andrews
“My family and I agreed that this may well have the best ice cream we've ever had. Absolutely delicious. The service was really good, and they had a good sense of humor, with the servers having a list of why they would like tips (one said because they wanted money... lol... most others for college, et .). It's definitely worth going to.”
- Marielys Mendoza
“Sally’s Ice Cream is a small, cozy little shop in Flagler Beach, but don’t let its size fool you—its ice cream is absolutely delicious. Truly, delicious isn’t even enough to describe it! The texture is incredibly smooth, the creaminess is perfect, and the flavors… wow. Every scoop tastes fresh, real, and made with care. You can feel the love in every bite. It’s the kind of place where you try one flavor and immediately want to come back to try them all. Even though it’s a small spot, it has a special charm that makes it unforgettable. Sally’s is the kind of place that brightens your day the moment you walk in—and completely wins you over once you taste their ice cream. If you’re in Flagler Beach, this place is an absolute must. A sweet little corner that truly deserves a visit. 🍦✨”
Hours
- Monday
- Tuesday
- Closed
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
Highlights
- Popular for solo dining
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Dogs allowed outside
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Family-friendly
- Cozy
Show more amenities
- Onsite services
- Solo dining
- Restroom
- Quiet
- Trendy
- Groups
- Accessibility· 4
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Assistive hearing loop
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Parking· 2
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- Family-friendly· 1
- Good for kids
- Dining options· 1
- Table service
- Atmosphere· 1
- Casual
- Planning· 1
- Quick visit