Skip to main content
BusinessesMap
The Mill on the River — American Restaurants in South Windsor

The Mill on the River

American RestaurantsSouth Windsor, CT

4.5 out of 5 stars4.5(2,926 reviews)

Quick info

+1 860-289-7929
989 Ellington Rd, South Windsor, CT 06074, United States
moderate

About The Mill on the River

Set in a former grist mill on Ellington Rd in South Windsor, The Mill on the River is an American restaurant with water views and an outdoor seating area. The menu includes mussels in a creamy white sauce with Parmesan, calamari as an appetizer, and complimentary bread and butter to start. Lobster pasta, vodka pasta, and shrimp scampi are recurring entree orders. Service is walk-in, and the restaurant gets packed, so arriving without a firm plan for a table is part of the experience. Staff or the manager come around to check in on guests during the meal. It opens Tuesday through Sunday and closes on Mondays, drawing diners for both regular meals and special occasions in the mill setting by the water.

Reviews

4.5/5
2,926 reviews

What reviewers say

Reviewers most often mention lobster pasta, shrimp scampi, calamari and mussels.

5★
2,103
4★
475
3★
145
2★
71
1★
132

Customer Review Summary

Reviewers consistently point to the lobster pasta and mussels as standout dishes, alongside shrimp scampi and calamari that several diners call fresh and flavorful. Vodka pasta, crabcake, and complimentary bread or rolls also draw repeated praise, and desserts like the vanilla bean creme brulee and basque cheesecake come up often as highlights. Many describe the setting by the water and near the fireplace as beautiful, with attentive servers and a manager who checks in on tables. One diner, however, described an anniversary dinner marred by a tiny bread portion, an undersized salad, and a lobster pasta whose vodka sauce arrived thin and flavorless rather than the expected orange sauce, calling the value poor. Reservations are mentioned as helpful given how packed the dining room gets. Several say they plan to return, with one noting it has become a regular stop since celebrating a family milestone there.

Featured reviews

  • Santa Gonzalez
    “What a beautiful spot!!! The atmosphere was good, the service was great. Shoutout to Amanda who was attentive and James, the new manager for taking the time to come up to our table and find out how things were going. The food was good, I’m not giving it five starts because I have had better eggplant parm, but it was good either way. I had requested for the best table if possible and we had a good spot.”
  • Dominic Scalia
    “Started off poorly when one tiny piece of bread was placed on our plates. Never in my life have I experienced that. Then the salad comes out. I think I could have grabbed it with my hand and ate it in one bite. Massive plate for the smallest portion of salad I’ve ever seen. And they have the audacity to charge $13 for it. Pretty much charged $1 per lettuce leaf. I got the fra diavolo and my girlfriend got the lobster pasta. Mine was alright, the mussels and scallops were good, but I finished it in probably 30 seconds because again I could have grabbed the thing in one hand and ate it all at once. Now to the lobster pasta. The lobster was alright, but the sauce… It said on the menu it came with vodka sauce. The sauce was like a clear/white color (vodka sauce is supposed to be orange), and it was flavorless. It literally seemed like they just put the pasta water back on the pasta and called it a day. I cannot believe I just spent $150 for an anniversary dinner here. Will never be returning.”
  • itsss_meee (itsss_meee)
    “This is the best restaurant in CT from the service to the rolls, the delicious lobster pasta and mussels, ambiance, oh and did I say rolls🤭. This has been my go to restaurant since I had a baby and they have always been so accommodating. The food always comes out in a good time even when packed to the brim and the staff are always soooo kind.”
  • Savanna Rivera
    “Fantastic place! Went for the first time to celebrate our wedding anniversary. Our waitress Abby was sweet, very attentive! The food was phenomenal, drinks also very tasty and quite an array of options for cocktails. The outdoor seating area is gorgeous. We are already planning our next visit”
  • Lia
    “Quite the fancy spot with gorgeous views of the water. Great food and drink menu with many fun mocktail options. We enjoyed the calamari, vegetable ravioli, and salads. Dessert didn't disappoint either, the basque cheesecake and banana walnut cake were delicious! Plenty of parking and tons of tables inside and outside, can imagine on a warm day sitting outside is lovely. We made a reservation so getting seated was quick and simple. Thanks for a lovely meal!”

Hours

Monday
Closed
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Good to know

“Special-occasion spot in a rustic former grist mill serving Continental fare plus a popular brunch.”

  • Reservations
    Walk-in only

Location

Browse more

Explore more of South Windsor.

DirectionsCallTop