
Big Bill's New York Pizza
Advertisements
Quick info
About Big Bill's New York Pizza
On S Holly St in Centennial, Colorado, Big Bill's New York Pizza is a pizza restaurant with a 122-dish menu built around thin, crispy NY-style pies and classic slices that are folded over. Pizzas come as red or white, and the Big Paulie is the meat lovers pie. Sicilian style pizza gives a thicker alternative to the thin-crust pies. Garlic knots come with marinara sauce as a side to share, and the kitchen also makes other Italian dishes beyond pizza. The restaurant serves Fuhgeddaboudit beer to go with the food. The decor is New York themed and reflects the owner's passion for the city.
Good to know
- ReservationsAccepts reservations
- ParkingFree parking lot · On-site parking
- AccessibilityWheelchair: entrance, parking lot, restroom, seating
- Good for kidsGood for kids · High chairs · Kids' menu
- DietaryVegetarian options
Advertisements
Menu & Prices
122 dishes · mains $2–27- Anchovies$1.75
- Bacon$1.75
- Black Olives$1.75
- Broccoli$1.75
- Capicola$1.75
- Chicken$6.00
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention garlic knots, nyc style pizza, crispy thin crust and tangy red sauce.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention garlic knots, nyc style pizza, crispy thin crust and tangy red sauce.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers often praise the New York style pizza, with crispy thin crust and tangy sauce, plus the Big Paulie meat lovers and a Sicilian slice. Garlic knots split opinion: filling for one, doughy inside or forgettable for others. Three lower reviews call the pizza forgettable, citing soggy crust, dry dough and cheese that broke apart. One was offered a remade pizza but said the manager never came over.
Customer Review Summary
Reviewers often praise the New York style pizza, with crispy thin crust and tangy sauce, plus the Big Paulie meat lovers and a Sicilian slice. Garlic knots split opinion: filling for one, doughy inside or forgettable for others. Three lower reviews call the pizza forgettable, citing soggy crust, dry dough and cheese that broke apart. One was offered a remade pizza but said the manager never came over.
Featured reviews
- Roland Asmolkov
“Very good, traditional NYC pizza spot, well staffed, friendly and attentive, the spot has a very unique atmosphere with NYC style that makes you feel like you are in a busy city. I would say it’s a great place to have a small family dinner (1-6 people) and discuss some nostalgic memories while enjoying an amazing pizza with great beer with slightly hoppy profile (Fuhgeddaboudit). We got red pizza and white pizza with garlic knots and some salads. Obviously pizza takes the spotlight: both pizzas were crispy, hot - right out of the oven, flavor profile was balanced and you could taste every ingredient: the crispy crust in famous NYC style, the sauce tanginess and the cheese. I would call it a great balance in flavor if you like excellent pizza. I will be returning to this place.”
- Ash Rit
“No wonder why this place was so busy. It was delicious!! Some of the best pizza I’ve had and the service was great too. I can’t wait to go back and try more stuff!”
- Alex DeMartino
“The only thing worth coming here for is the atmosphere. The good itself is ok at best. We got a veggie ny style, garlic knots and a stuffed shells. The pizza was not bad but also not memorable in any way. The shells were again ok but not notable. The knots kept the same trend.”
- Rick Winnard
“This is a classic New York style pizzeria Italiano place to be. It's such a joy to have conversations with perfect strangers. The decor is dedicated to the owners passion for NY. The food is absolutely incredible while still priced for value. For those with liter appetites enjoy a classic slice of NY pie fold over and all. I enjoyed the Sicilian style. Perfect!”
- George Rose
“This place is great. Great old school feel inside. The staff was super nice. I had the "Big Paulie" - a fantastic/filling meat lovers NY style pizza--see picture. Prices are very reasonable. Bill's is now my favorite pizza place! Best pizza in Colorado!”
Hours
- Monday
- Tuesday
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
Highlights
“New York-centric pizzeria for classic thin-crust pies, slices & other Italian staples, plus beer.”
- Fast service
- Serves local specialty
- Popular for lunch
- Popular for dinner
- Popular for solo dining
- Vegetarian options
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Accepts reservations
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
- Family-friendly
Show more amenities
- Vegetarian options
- Alcohol
- Cozy
- Onsite services
- Beer
- Coffee
- Dining options· 6
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
- Highlights· 2
- Fast service
- Serves local specialty
- Facilities· 1
- Restroom
- Offerings· 3
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
- Wine
- Atmosphere· 1
- Casual
- Accessibility· 3
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Parking· 2
- Free parking lot
- On-site parking
- Service options· 1
- Curbside pickup
- Popular for· 1
- Solo dining
- Crowd· 3
- College students
- Groups
- Tourists
- Family-friendly· 3
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Kids' menu