
Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery
Advertisements
Quick info
About Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery
On Lincoln Blvd in Santa Monica, Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery is an Italian deli and market with a menu of 223 items. The Godmother sandwich layers prosciutto, ham, capicola, mortadella, Genoa salami and provolone, and it can be ordered with hot peppers or "spicy" and "with the works." Sandwiches come in small and large sizes, and the list also includes a meatball sandwich. Burrata sits on the menu as well. Some popular sandwiches are premade for grab and go. Orders run by ticket: take a number at the counter and wait for it to be called. The market side stocks packaged salads and pasta, imported goods and many chili sauces. Payment is cash or debit only, and a small ATM is inside.
Advertisements
Menu & Prices
223 dishes · mains $2–140- Ricotta - Fresh$4.00
- Burrata$12.00
- Water Mozzarella$5.00
- 4 Alarm Cheddar$7.00
- Mozzarella Shredded$6.00
- Prairie Breeze$9.00
Reviews
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention godmother sandwich, pesto burrata caprese, pastrami sandwich and turkey sub.
What reviewers say
Reviewers most often mention godmother sandwich, pesto burrata caprese, pastrami sandwich and turkey sub.
Customer Review Summary
Most reviewers come for the Godmother, stuffed with prosciutto, capicola, mortadella and salami, some adding hot peppers. Pastrami, tuna, turkey and sausage sandwiches also earn praise, as does the ricotta cheesecake. One reviewer calls parking and the line to order a hassle, and another finds the bread tough with fillings slipping out. One says the half saved for later never makes it home.
Customer Review Summary
Most reviewers come for the Godmother, stuffed with prosciutto, capicola, mortadella and salami, some adding hot peppers. Pastrami, tuna, turkey and sausage sandwiches also earn praise, as does the ricotta cheesecake. One reviewer calls parking and the line to order a hassle, and another finds the bread tough with fillings slipping out. One says the half saved for later never makes it home.
Featured reviews
- Margaux
“Absolutely amazing experience! ❤️ We’re visiting from Poland and, to be honest, we had no idea how to order at first. But the gentleman immediately noticed our confusion and kindly stepped in to help us choose. He made us feel so welcome and comfortable. Such a warm, friendly atmosphere and genuinely lovely service! And the sandwiches… WOW! Some of the best sandwiches we’ve ever had. The famous Godmother was absolutely incredible, generously stuffed, packed with fresh ingredients, and bursting with flavour. The pastrami sandwich was just as fantastic! Everything was fresh, delicious, and made with so much care. Between the amazing food and the kindness of the staff, this place is an absolute gem. Thank you for making us feel so welcome! We’ll definitely remember this place and recommend it to everyone. If you’re in the area it is a MUST-VISIT! ❤️🇮🇹”
- FilipinoEats
“We appreciate their Godmother sandwich—it is outstanding. Although the cost is somewhat high for a sandwich, the quality matches the price. I am also pleased they deliver through DoorDash; the line grows longer and busier there. This lets me enjoy the sandwich at home.”
- Evan Goodwin
“I’d been wanting to try this place for awhile, after seeing so many others rate it online and on social media. The hype was worth it. What looks like an intimidating ordering situations was actually really easy. I think I was expecting a NYC style service counter where you get yelled at if you don’t know exactly what you want, but the staff was so nice and helpful. My wife and I split the whole turkey sub with mild peppers and American cheese, no pickles. The bread was great—a little on the crusty side, but otherwise very flavorful. All of the veggies and meat were very fresh, and the experience was cool over all. You grab a ticket at the counter, wait for them to call your number, then you order and step back while they make yours and a handful of others at the same time. I grabbed some chips and drinks while I waited, which only took 5 minutes or so, then paid at the front (cash or debit only) and enjoyed our lunch at one of the outdoor tables. I’ll definitely be back to try the meatball sub, which I eyed somebody else eating and immediately wanted a taste. I’ll probably grab a turkey sub, too, while I’m at it.”
- h fitz
“Eating from bay cities will require you to fight with your food. The bread will be tough and the fixins will keep slipping out. But for $12.50 (for a small, $15.00 for a large), you’ll happily take that fight any day. All of the sandwiches are packed with tasty meats or vegetables and the works (a combo of mayo lettuce onion Italian dressing etc). You might decide to eat one half and save the rest for the later, though don’t be shocked when, at the end of the meal, there’s nothing left to take home.”
- Mark
“I go here when I'm in the area. The sandwich to get is the spicy Gdmother with the works. People line up for this sandwich. They also make them ahead of time as they are so popular. I actually got the tuna the last few times which is also amazing. Their bread is so fresh - crunchy on the outside yet soft on the inside. This is a must go to place! Be prepared to try and find a parking space and to wait in line but it is well worth it. It's also an Italian deli where you can find all things Italian. For payment, they take cash or debit cards. They have a small ATM machine in the store. Although parking is typically a hassle and the wait inside to order sandwiches is also a hassle, it is well worth it.”
Hours
- Monday
- Closed
- Tuesday
- Closed
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
Good to know
“Local staple known for its signature overstuffed sandwiches, Italian deli fare & gourmet groceries.”
- ParkingFree parking lot · On-site parking · Paid street parking
- AccessibilityWheelchair: entrance, parking lot
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Delivery
- Takeout
- In-store pickup
- Onsite services
- Restroom
Show more amenities
- Free parking lot
- Quick visit
- Parking· 2
- On-site parking
- Paid street parking
- Service options· 1
- In-store shopping
- Accessibility· 1
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Location
More to explore in Santa Monica
Places in Santa Monica
See all places in Santa Monica