Cosa Nostra

Featured reviews

• B

  Babs BD

  ·1 month ago

  “Staff were very friendly and helpful, and the food was lovely (highly recommend the nibbles). Calzone was huge as delicious. One star off atmosphere because of bright lighting made it less than cosy. Would highly recommend.”

• O

  Orlagh O’Connor

  ·1 month ago

  “Absolutely amazing , family meal with one older child. Children’s portions were generous (pizza). Adults food was indescribably delicious. Starters - bruschetta , lobster ravioli , plenty enough to share. Tomato’s were full of flavour. Mains- Ragu , salmon and carbonara, all delicious. Compliments to chefs true talent. Atmosphere was busy but enjoyable. Service was 5 starts , prompt and professional with all staff aswell as being friendly. Special mention to Finley who was informative personal and overall made for a great experience dining here. Exceeded all expectations would definitely recommend. Well done to everyone who works here chefs and waiters ❤️”

  Read more
• F

  fia x

  ·2 months ago

  “We really wanted to try this Italian after seeing the reviews and it was worth the visit, despite it being more expensive then most places the quality of the food exceeds expectations and was amazing. We got the tagliatelle ragu which was full of flavour and was by far one of the best pasta dishes I’ve ever tried. We also got a garlic bread to share and was one of the best garlic breads I’ve ever had, full of garlic and cheese and flavour, so tasty. Everything was amazing from the super friendly staff that were attentive despite being very busy to the delicious food. Please if you come to Whitby try this Italian it is amazing!”

  Read more
• D

  David porter

  ·3 months ago

  “1st night in Whitby and we didn't fancy the usual fish and chips. Found this restaurant and managed to get a table. So glad we did as the food was delicious. The staff were really friendly and really helpful. I would definitely recommend this place. My daughter loves her steak and said this was one of the best she'd ever had”

  Read more
• G

  Georgia Roberts

  ·3 months ago

  “Lovely food. Great selection on the menu. Friendly staff. Incredibly busy when we arrived for our 6.45pm reservation and the noise level was bit too much for me. Obviously not something that can be helped. We were just unlucky it was heaving and loud. Would definitely go again but perhaps a lunchtime might be quieter for me.”

  Read more

• A

  Anastasiya

  ·3 months ago

  “A solid choice when in Whitby. Food is good but I think that the prices are bit too high for the taste of the food. The waitresses were very friendly, and the service is quick.”

• J

  Joshua Kerley

  ·4 months ago

  “We had a lovely wedding anniversary meal here. All the food was excellent (the calzone was huge and delicious, and we were sent home with the leftovers) the service was great and we got a lovely table upstairs which was perfect for our date!”

• G

  G

  ·4 months ago

  “Food was great! But I couldn't enjoy my food properly due to being sat literally next to the bar in a small area. Glass was smashed which went all under the table, partially on my chair which I wiped off and found out a few minutes later that it was on the table because I also put my hand in it and got a shard stuck in my hand. Luckily only stuck a little hole in my hand but if it had been a bigger piece of glass it could have been different or any went in our drinks. I was more shocked they didn't just move us from that table. I understand they may have been booked up but temporarily while they cleaned it and then could have swapped the next people coming in to sit there once cleaned. I had to ask for fresh drinks rather than them offer as I was then worried shards may have gone in my drink if it managed to make its way high enough to the table. So glad I asked them to change them because I didn't fancy trying my odds. I don't think that table is appropriate anyway as we were again sandwiched by the bar. It would prevent things like the above happening because they also dropped a few other things while we were eating too. I was disappointed because the food was absolutely lovely and I just wish I could have enjoyed the restaurant more than I did but this ruined it for me. The staff however were lovely. I just wish they would have done things differently as stated above.”

  Read more
• P

  Phil Leach

  ·4 months ago

  “Went on a Thursday evening. Really pleasant greeting and shown to table straight away. Sat on the balcony so had a great view of the whole restaurant which is very nice. Staff were very attentive giving us plenty of time to look at the menu and decide what we wanted from the great choice. Food arrived quickly, was hot and delicious. My wife opted for 2 starters (these were big portions) and I had tagliatelle ragu. My pasta was cooked perfectly and the ragu (of which there was a lot of) was absolutely gorgeous. The bill was quite reasonable and definitely great value for money in terms of the service and food received. Will definitely come back if we visit Whitby again!”

  Read more
• J

  Jan Rhodes

  ·4 months ago

  “Lovely Italian restaurant in Whitby across the swing bridge. Quirky interior with a few tables downstairs where the kitchen is, but then there's another three levels up alot of stairs. The tables upstairs are all situated on different levels all overlooking the whole restaurant. If you're not good going up and down stairs make sure you ask when you book for a ground floor table. Nb. The toilets are also downstairs. Few vegetarian dishes. I had a artichoke and pesto pizza with caramelised red onion £17.25, very tasty. My partner had Penne Arrabbiatta £15.95 which he said was good but not very spicey. We also had garlic mushrooms £9.50 which were ok, a bit watery and lacked flavour & Tiger Prawns with roasted red peppers £10.75 which my partner said were very tasty.”

  Read more